Tax relief for charity property debated

Summary#

The enacted short title is the Hot Docs Act (Tax Relief), 2019; the supplied bill listing calls it the 2020 bill. It is a stand-alone Ontario law, not an amendment to another Act. Its goal is to allow Toronto to grant tax relief on one Hot Docs property.

  • Toronto City Council may pass a by-law exempting the property at 504 Bloor Street West from municipal taxes, except local improvement rates, starting January 1, 2020.
  • The exemption depends on Hot Docs being the registered owner and registered charity, and on the property being occupied and used solely by Hot Docs.
  • If Toronto grants the municipal exemption, the property is also exempt from school taxes for the same period. The city may also cancel past municipal taxes, interest and penalties; school taxes, interest and penalties are cancelled for the same period.
  • A by-law may require Hot Docs to agree to repay taxes that would have been payable if the relief had not been granted, if it sells, leases or otherwise disposes of the property.
  • If Hot Docs acquires other Toronto land within two years and meets the stated conditions, the city may transfer the exemption to that land. The agreement may defer repayment until the replacement land is disposed of.

What it means for you#

  • Hot Docs: The Act does not automatically grant tax relief. Toronto City Council must choose to pass the by-law. Any part of the property used by another entity is not exempt.
  • Toronto and school boards: If the city grants the municipal exemption, school-tax relief follows for the same period. The city and school boards share any repayment under an agreement in the same proportions as they would have shared the taxes.
  • Toronto taxpayers: The relief may mean less tax revenue from this property while the exemption applies. Local improvement rates are not exempt.
  • People and organizations generally: The Act applies to the named property and Hot Docs; it does not create a general tax exemption for other charities.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of the tax revenue affected or the cost of administering the relief.

  • Municipal and school taxes may be forgone for the period covered by a city by-law; local improvement rates remain payable.
  • The city may cancel past taxes, interest and penalties for the covered period.
  • If an agreement requires repayment when the property is disposed of, the amount is based on taxes that would have been payable, for up to 10 years or the shorter period specified in the Act.

What is unclear#

  • The Act does not require Toronto to pass a by-law, or set out how the council should decide whether to do so.
  • It does not define “occupied and used solely” or explain how shared use would be assessed.
  • It does not set out an application process, decision timelines, appeals or reporting requirements.
  • The amount of relief and any repayment would depend on the taxes that would otherwise have been payable; no figures are provided.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to reduce tax costs for a named charity using its property for its own purposes.
  • Making the exemption depend on a city by-law gives Toronto a choice about whether to grant it.
  • The repayment agreement and possible transfer to replacement property could let Hot Docs relocate while protecting the city’s ability to recover some taxes.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the city and school boards may lose tax revenue, while the Act provides no estimate of the amount.
  • The Act creates a special tax option for one property and organization, rather than a general rule for similar properties.
  • The city’s decision process and the meaning of exclusive use are not set out, leaving important details to be worked out.