Bill Would Order Zebra Mussel Probe

Summary#

Bill 17, the Counting Zebra Mussels Act, 2018, would create a new Act. It would require Ontario’s Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation into the extent of the zebra mussel problem in specified waterways. Its stated goal is to have the Minister determine the zebra mussel content of those waterways.

  • The required investigation covers the waterways named in the schedule: Casgrain Creek, Casgrain Lake, Cash Creek, Cashel Lake, Cashman Creek, Cashore Creek, Casino Lake, Caskie Bay, Caskill Lake, Cask Lake, Casper Lake, Casque Lake, Cassdaga Lake, Casselman's Lake, Casselman's Creek, Cassels Lake, Cassidy Bay, Cassidy Creek, Cassidy Lake, Cassidys Bay, Cass Lake, Casson Lake, Castellar Creek, Castellar Lake, Castlebar Creek, Castlebar Lake, Castle Bay, Castle Creek, Castle Lake, Castleman Lake, Castlewood Creek, Castlewood Lake, Castor Creek, Castor Lake, Castoroil Lake, Castor Ponds, Castor River, Castra Lake, Casurnmit Lake, Caswell Bay, Casvell Lake, Cataract Falls, Cataract Lake, Cataraqui Bay and Cataraqui River.
  • The bill uses a duty: the Minister “shall” direct the investigation. It cites subsection 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act, but does not amend that Act.
  • The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People and communities near the listed waterways: The Minister would have to direct an investigation there. The bill does not say how the investigation would be done or require residents or property owners to take part.
  • The public: The bill does not create a ban, fee, benefit, or new enforcement power. It does not require the Minister to publish findings.
  • Government: The Minister would have a legal duty to direct the investigation. The bill does not set a deadline or specify who would carry it out.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Minister to direct an investigation, but gives no estimate of its cost, staffing needs, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “extent” or “zebra mussel content,” or set a method for measuring either.
  • It gives no deadline, reporting requirement, or rule for making results public.
  • It does not say whether the investigation must use the same method or provide the same level of detail for every listed waterway.
  • The Ontario Water Resources Act is not supplied, so I could not verify what subsection 15(1) requires under current law or how this bill’s duty would interact with it.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to establish what the zebra mussel problem is in particular named waterways.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that investigations could provide local information for understanding the problem. The bill does not guarantee what the investigation will find or what action would follow.
  • Naming the waterways makes the places covered by the required investigation specific.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set a deadline, method, or requirement to publish findings, so it is unclear when the public would get useful results or how detailed they would be.
  • “Extent” and “zebra mussel content” are not defined, leaving unclear what would count as a complete investigation.
  • The bill requires an investigation but provides no cost estimate or specified funding.