Bill orders zebra mussel investigation in waterways

Summary#

Bill 22, the Zebra Mussel Scan Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation under that Act into the zebra mussel problem in named waterways. The stated goal is to determine their zebra mussel content.

  • The required investigation would cover every waterway named in the bill’s schedule: Chain Creek, Chain Lake, Chain Lakes, The Chain of Lakes, Chainy Creek, Chainy Lake, Chair Lake; Chalet Creek, Chalet Lake, Chalice Lake, Chalk Bay, Chalk Creek, Chalkend Lake, Chalk Lake, Chalk River, Challener Lake, Challener River, Challis Lake, Chalmers Lake, Chamandy Lake, Chamberlain Lake, Chamber Lake, Chambers Lake, Champagne Lake, Champlain Creek, Champlain Trail Lakes, Chance Lake, Chancellor Lake, Chandos Lake, Change Lake, Chanley Lake, Channel Lake, Channel Lakes; Green River, Greenrod Lake, Greens Bay, Green’s Creek, Greenshields Lake, Greenshore Lake, Greensides Lake, Greens Lake, Greenstone Rapids, Greensward Lake, Green Tree Lake, Greenwater Creek, Greenwater Lake, Greenwich Creek, Greenwich Lake, Greenwood Lake and Greenwood River.
  • The bill says the Minister must direct the investigation. It does not specify who would carry it out or what methods they must use.
  • If enacted, the Act would come into force on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Minister: Must direct an investigation into the listed waterways. The bill does not require a particular method or set out what the investigation must produce.
  • People who use or live near the listed waterways: The bill does not create a new duty for you, require you to take part, or set out any changes to access or use.
  • General public: The bill does not create a treatment, prevention or removal program for zebra mussels.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Minister to direct an investigation but does not set out a budget or funding source.
  • It gives no estimate of the cost of the investigation.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the text of subsection 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act, so its existing requirements and how this bill relates to them could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define the “extent” of the zebra mussel problem or describe how the investigation must determine it.
  • It sets no deadline and does not require a report to the public or the Legislature.
  • It does not say what action, if any, must follow the investigation.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that investigating named waterways could provide information about the extent of the zebra mussel problem there.
  • Requiring the Minister to direct an investigation gives the work a clear government lead.
  • Naming the waterways in the law makes clear which places the required investigation must cover.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set a timeline, investigation method or reporting requirement, so the scope and public visibility of the work are unclear.
  • It requires an investigation but does not require any response to its findings.
  • The bill does not state how the investigation would be funded or what it would cost.