Bill orders zebra mussel survey of waterways

Summary#

Bill 19, the Zebra Mussel Survey Act, 2018, would create a standalone Ontario law; it does not amend the text of the Ontario Water Resources Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to direct an investigation into the zebra mussel problem in named waterways. Its stated goal is to have the Minister determine the zebra mussel content of those waterways.

  • The investigation would cover: Cayer Lake, Cayiens Creek, Caysee Lake, Cayuga Creek, Cayuga Lake, Cebush Lake, Cecebe Lake, Cecil Creek, Cecile Lake, Cedar Bay, Cedarbough Lake, Cedarclump Lake, Cedar Creek, Cedar Falls, Cedargum Lake, Cedar Harbour, Cedar Lake, Cedar Rapids, Cedar River, Cedarskirt Lake, Cedric Lake, Cee Creek, Ceepee Lake, Celastruc Lake, Cellist Lake, Celt Creek, Celtis Lake, Celt Lake, Cemetery Creek, Cemetery Lake, Centennial Lake, Centralis Creek, Centralis Lake, Central Lake, Centre Channel, Centre Creek, Centre Falls, Centrefire Creek, Centrefire Lake, Centre Lake, Centreville Creek, Ceph Lake, Ceres Lake, Cerulean Lake, Cerullo Lake, Chabbie Lake, Chabbie River, Chabot Lake, Chadwick Lake, Chagma Lake, Chagnon Lake and Chaillon Lake.
  • The Act would start on the day it receives Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • The minister and ministry: The minister must direct an investigation covering the waterways listed above. The bill does not say who must carry it out or require a particular method or report.
  • People and businesses near those waterways: The bill does not directly change anyone’s rights, duties, taxes, fees or access to the waterways.
  • The bill refers to subsection 15(1) of the Ontario Water Resources Act. The supplied materials do not include that Act, so it is not possible to verify what responsibility already exists under current law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the minister to direct an investigation but sets no funding amount, staffing level or cost estimate.
  • It does not set out a fee, tax, fine or payment.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what counts as the “extent” of the zebra mussel problem or specify how the investigation must determine zebra mussel content.
  • It gives no deadline, required report, or rules for sharing results with the public.
  • It does not say who will conduct or pay for the investigation.
  • Without the Ontario Water Resources Act, it is unclear how this new requirement relates to the minister’s existing responsibilities under that Act.

Case for#

  • The bill would require an investigation of zebra mussels in each waterway it names, rather than leaving whether to direct one to the minister’s discretion.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that information about zebra mussels in those waterways could help inform later decisions. The bill itself does not require any particular follow-up action.

Case against#

  • The bill requires an investigation but does not set a deadline, method, reporting rule or standard for what the investigation must establish.
  • It does not identify who will do the work or provide funding. That leaves the likely cost and how the requirement would be carried out unclear.
  • The bill’s reference to an existing responsibility under the Ontario Water Resources Act makes the missing parent Act important: the supplied materials do not show how much this bill would add to current law.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2018080701

    Passed55 members voted

    On motion by Mr. Bisson, Bill 19, An Act to require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to discharge the responsibilities under subsection 15 (1) of the Ontario…

    FOR · 55

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    55For

    • PC35
    • NDP19
    • Liberal1

    0Against