Summary#
Bill 187, the Municipal Emergency Act, 2020, is an enacted law that amends Ontario’s Municipal Act, 2001 and City of Toronto Act, 2006. Its stated aim is to let municipal and Toronto councils make electronic participation work during declared emergencies. It also gives the Lieutenant Governor in Council power to make regulations limiting or setting conditions on municipalities’ powers under section 129 of the Municipal Act, 2001.
- During a declared emergency, a municipality’s procedure by-law may allow council, local board and committee members taking part electronically to count toward quorum (the minimum number needed to conduct business).
- If the by-law allows it, those members may also take part electronically in meetings closed to the public.
- Municipalities and local boards may hold special meetings during an emergency to amend their procedure by-laws for these purposes. Electronic participants may count toward quorum at those special meetings.
- Toronto has similar options for city council, local boards and committees. Only Toronto’s head of council may call a special city council meeting for this purpose.
- The bill does not require any council or board to adopt these options; it makes them available through procedure by-laws.
What it means for you#
- Municipal and Toronto council, local board and committee members: During a qualifying declared emergency, your procedure by-law may let you attend electronically, count toward quorum and take part in a closed meeting.
- Municipalities and local boards: You may hold a special meeting during an emergency to amend the procedure by-law. The bill does not require you to do so.
- Toronto city council: Its head of council alone may call a special city council meeting to make this kind of by-law change.
- Residents: The bill does not require meetings to be electronic, change which meetings may be closed to the public, or require public access to closed meetings.
- Municipalities: The provincial cabinet may make regulations setting limits or conditions on municipal powers under section 129. The supplied material does not say what those limits or conditions would be.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill text contains no spending amount, funding provision, fee or cost estimate.
- It gives no estimate of the cost of changing procedure by-laws or holding electronic meetings.
What is unclear#
- The procedure by-laws would set the details of electronic participation; the bill does not set technical rules or require a particular system.
- The bill does not say whether or when municipalities or boards will use the new options.
- The content of any future regulations on municipal powers under section 129 is not specified.
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so the current rules and the scope of section 129 could not be independently checked against the full Acts.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that councils and boards may need to keep meeting during emergencies when members cannot attend in person.
- Letting electronic participants count toward quorum could help a body conduct business when fewer members can meet physically.
- Allowing electronic participation in closed meetings could let councils and boards continue work on matters that are legally closed to the public.
Case against#
- The bill does not require councils or boards to adopt the options, so electronic participation is not assured during an emergency.
- The bill does not set technical or procedural safeguards for electronic participation; those details depend on local procedure by-laws.
- The bill gives the provincial cabinet authority to set limits or conditions on municipal powers under section 129, but does not state what those rules might be.