Tax and borrowing update

Summary#

The Economic and Fiscal Update Act, 2020 is an enacted Ontario law. It amends several existing Acts and creates two laws: a temporary law giving tribunals more control over hearing formats, and a law authorizing provincial borrowing. Its stated goal is to make economic and fiscal changes; that goal is not a guaranteed result.

  • Taxes: For 2020, the Employer Health Tax exemption amount for eligible employers is $1 million. The Act also creates a refundable investment tax credit for qualifying corporations that buy certain property in specified Ontario regions, and changes a rule for a film and television production tax credit.
  • Income support: Eligible recipients under the Ontario Guaranteed Annual Income Act are to receive double the usual increment payment from April 1 to September 30, 2020.
  • Borrowing: The Crown may borrow up to $31.2 billion under the Ontario Loan Act, 2020. This is borrowing authority, not an order to spend that amount.
  • Tribunal hearings: Specified tribunals may choose to hold hearings in person, electronically, in writing, or in a combination of formats. The law applies to ongoing proceedings and is repealed on a date set by proclamation.
  • Personal health information: Health information custodians must keep electronic audit logs and audit and monitor them as regulations require. The Act also changes when health information may be collected, used, or disclosed, and adds enforcement powers and penalties.
  • Data integration: The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act’s rules for data integration units are extended to extra-ministerial units designated by regulation. Their members may use personal information collected under those rules only to link and de-identify it.

What it means for you#

  • People eligible for the income payment: Their increment payment was doubled for the six-month period in 2020. This is not a general increase to every income-support payment.
  • Employers: Eligible employers had a $1 million Employer Health Tax exemption amount for 2020. The bill does not state which employers qualify; that depends on the existing Act.
  • Businesses investing in specified regions: A qualifying Canadian-controlled private corporation may claim a refundable credit of 10% of eligible expenditures, subject to limits and conditions. Eligible property must be certain depreciable capital property located wholly in a qualifying region. The named regions are Bruce, Chatham-Kent, Elgin, Essex, Frontenac, Grey, Haliburton, Hastings, Huron, Kawartha Lakes, Lambton, Lanark, Leeds and Grenville, Lennox and Addington, Middlesex, Northumberland, Oxford, Perth, Peterborough, Prescott and Russell, Prince Edward, Renfrew, Stormont, Dundas and Glengarry, Algoma, Cochrane, Kenora, Manitoulin, Muskoka, Nipissing, Parry Sound, Rainy River, Sudbury, Thunder Bay, and Timiskaming. The Minister of Finance may add areas or exclude land. The property must meet further conditions, including becoming available for use on or after March 25, 2020.
  • Patients and health care providers: People have a right to access their health records in an electronic format that meets prescribed requirements, subject to prescribed limits. Health information custodians must keep audit logs when they use electronic means to handle personal health information. The Act also allows certain uses or disclosures for health care payments, school immunization matters, coroners’ investigations, and public health duties, with conditions that vary by purpose.
  • Health data services and people whose records they hold: The Act allows rules for consumer electronic service providers that help people manage health records. A health information custodian is not required to answer an access request by sending records through such a provider.
  • People and organizations before tribunals: A tribunal may decide the hearing format and related matters, including notice, filing, attendance, recording, and public access. This is a power, not a requirement to hold hearings electronically.
  • Taxpayers: The borrowing authority does not itself create a new tax or require the full $31.2 billion to be borrowed.

Money#

The Act authorizes borrowing and changes tax payments and credits, but the supplied material gives no overall cost estimate.

  • The Crown may borrow up to $31.2 billion for provincial obligations or payments authorized by law. No spending plan or estimate of actual borrowing is provided.
  • The temporary income-payment increase and the tax measures affect public payments or revenue, but no fiscal estimates are provided.
  • The regional investment credit is refundable. Its rate is 10%, subject to expenditure limits and eligibility rules.
  • The health-information rules require custodians to maintain and monitor audit logs, but the bill gives no staffing or compliance cost estimate. Some details are left to regulations.
  • No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The full parent Acts and current consolidated laws are not included, so this summary cannot verify the changes against the complete law then in force or confirm whether later laws changed them.
  • Regulations must set some important details, including health-data audit requirements, consumer electronic service requirements, and the amounts and rules for administrative penalties.
  • The bill does not say which extra-ministerial data integration units will be designated, or how the government will choose them.
  • The tribunal law has no fixed repeal date in the text; repeal depends on a future proclamation.
  • No estimate is provided for the cost of the temporary income increase, tax changes, data and health-information requirements, or borrowing.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the tax changes is that they provide time-limited relief to eligible employers and income-support recipients, while offering a credit for some business investment in specified regions.
  • Allowing tribunals to choose hearing formats gives them legal authority to adapt how proceedings are held.
  • Audit logs, access rights, public reports, and new enforcement powers could strengthen oversight of personal health information.
  • Extending data-integration rules to designated outside units could allow them to link and de-identify information while placing limits and reporting duties on their use of it.

Case against#

  • The bill gives tribunals broad control over hearing formats and related procedures, and its rules can prevail over conflicting laws and tribunal rules. The text does not set detailed protections for access to hearings or participation.
  • Some health-data and privacy safeguards depend on future regulations. The bill does not itself set all the practical rules for audits, service providers, or administrative-penalty amounts.
  • The loan authority allows borrowing up to $31.2 billion, but the bill does not provide an estimate of how much will be borrowed or explain the associated costs.
  • The tax credits and payment increase may reduce public revenue or increase spending, but the supplied material does not quantify those effects.