Bill extends loan pause and planning deadlines

Summary#

Bill 189, the Coronavirus (COVID-19) Support and Protection Act, 2020, was enacted as Chapter 6 of Ontario’s 2020 statutes. It amended five existing Acts: the Development Charges Act, 1997, Education Act, Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities Act, Planning Act and Police Services Act. Its stated goal was to address COVID-19; most of its changes were temporary rules or powers for the emergency period.

  • Certain municipal development-charge by-laws that expired or were due to expire during the specified emergency period were kept in force until the earlier of repeal or six months after the emergency ended. Education development-charge by-laws were also extended, but could not be amended to raise their rates; the Act provides for this extension rule to be repealed on a date set by proclamation.
  • Eligible student and medical resident loan borrowers did not have to make payments from March 30 to September 30, 2020, or a later date set by regulation. Interest did not accrue against borrowers during that period, and the responsible ministers had to establish revised loan agreements and notify borrowers.
  • The Act barred many legal claims against the Crown and related officials over the loan changes, including claims based on earlier events. Proceedings already started were deemed dismissed, without costs. The Crown could still bring proceedings.
  • The Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing may make regulations changing how certain planning-law time periods apply during an emergency. Regulations may apply retroactively and may override relevant provisions of the Planning Act, its regulations, and section 114 of the City of Toronto Act, 2006.
  • The Solicitor General may set a date for municipalities to adopt their first community safety and well-being plan. A municipal council must adopt the plan before the later of that date and the second anniversary of when the requirement began applying to the municipality.
  • For a pupil suspended when an order closes all schools, if no expulsion decision had been made at closure, a director of education may—on a principal’s recommendation—make an exception to an existing rule. The school board generally cannot expel the pupil more than 20 school days after the closure order ends, unless the parties agree to a later deadline.

What it means for you#

  • Student and medical resident loan borrowers: During the suspension period, you did not have to make loan payments, and interest did not accrue against you on covered loans. Any payments you made during that period had to go toward principal. The pause applied only to loans administered by the listed financial institutions or service providers, and to specified Crown debts.
  • Municipalities and developers: Some development-charge by-laws continued past their usual expiry date. The extension did not prevent a municipality from repealing a by-law. For education development charges, the extended by-law could not raise rates above the rate set when it would have expired.
  • Municipalities making safety plans: Councils had a duty to prepare and adopt a first plan by the later of the prescribed date and the second anniversary of when the requirement applied. The bill itself did not set the prescribed date.
  • Pupils, families and school boards: The bill changed a rule for a specific situation involving a suspension and school closure. The materials do not include the full existing rule that the director may set aside, so its precise effect cannot be confirmed here.
  • General public: The Act did not create a general COVID-19 cash benefit or change tax rates.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The ministers had to pay specified interest on some student loans and medical resident loans during the suspension period. The amount is not stated.
  • The Minister of Training, Colleges and Universities had to establish revised loan agreements and notify borrowers. No administrative cost is given.
  • The materials do not estimate costs or revenue effects from extending development-charge by-laws or changing planning timelines.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so the existing rules and the exact change to them could not be checked against their full text.
  • The materials do not say whether the education development-charge extension rule’s repeal by proclamation took effect, or what regulations were made under the Act.
  • The loan suspension ended on September 30, 2020, unless extended by regulation. The materials do not say whether it was extended or give the final suspension period.
  • The bill does not set a new community-plan deadline itself; it authorizes the Solicitor General to prescribe one.
  • It is unclear how the school-closure rule interacted with the full expulsion process, because the relevant existing provisions are not included.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent some by-laws and planning deadlines from expiring or running out during an emergency.
  • A payment pause and interest relief could give covered borrowers temporary financial breathing room during the suspension period.
  • Extending education development-charge by-laws while barring rate increases could preserve existing charges without allowing higher rates during the extension.
  • Giving the government power to adjust planning timelines could help address deadlines disrupted by an emergency.

Case against#

  • One concern is that ministers could change important planning rules through regulations, including retroactively and, in some cases, despite other laws.
  • The loan provisions sharply limited claims against the Crown and related officials, including by dismissing existing proceedings. The bill did not provide compensation for changes to contractual rights.
  • Extending development-charge by-laws could keep charges in place longer than their usual expiry date, while the bill did not explain how affected municipalities or developers would be consulted.
  • The Act left important details—such as any extended loan-pause date and some planning rules—to regulations not included in the supplied material.