Climate Health Plan Bill Creates Secretariat

Summary#

Bill 160, the Climate Crisis Health Action Plan Act, 2023, would create a new Ontario law. It would require the Minister of Health to publish and periodically review a plan, and establish a Climate Crisis and Health Secretariat and a science advisory board. The bill’s stated goal is to prepare Ontario’s public health and health care systems for health risks caused by the climate crisis.

  • The Minister must publish the plan within two years of the Act receiving Royal Assent and review it at least every four years. The plan must identify key health risks and vulnerable communities, and set out ways to communicate health strategies.
  • The plan must include government research programs, identify priority health care infrastructure projects, and set out modelling and forecasting tools. It must also include a plan for funding and guidance to help public health units and health care facilities assess vulnerabilities and make adaptation plans.
  • The plan must provide for systems to monitor a wide range of health and climate impacts, including infectious diseases, extreme heat, air and water quality, mental health, food insecurity and disruptions to medical care.
  • The Minister must establish a Secretariat and, as directed by the Minister of Health and the Environment Minister, it must carry out listed work including research, public communication, technical support to municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities, and preparedness plans and training.
  • The Minister must appoint a science advisory board of 10 to 20 people with expertise in public health, health care or climate science. The Minister must consult specified groups when developing or revising the plan, including representatives of First Nations, Inuit, Métis and Black communities.

What it means for you#

  • Public and patients: The bill would require planning and monitoring for climate-related health risks. It does not itself create a new patient service, guarantee a particular health outcome or change eligibility for health care.
  • Public health units and health care facilities: The plan must set out funding and guidance to help them assess their vulnerabilities and develop adaptation plans. The bill does not itself give them funding or require them to complete those plans.
  • Health professionals and research organizations: The plan must include research programs and communication strategies. The Secretariat must also develop training for health and public health professionals, as directed by the two ministers.
  • Municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities: The Secretariat must provide technical assistance and support in assessing preparedness and response strategies. The bill does not specify how much support, or how communities would take part in decisions.
  • Other named communities: The monitoring plan must cover the health of Indigenous, Black and racialized people, migrants, refugees, displaced people, low-income communities and other vulnerable communities. This is a requirement for monitoring, not a process to review individuals.

Money#

The bill requires planning for funding and a staffed Secretariat, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The plan must include a plan for funding and guidance for public health units and health care facilities; no amount or source of funding is specified.
  • The plan must establish government research programs, but the bill gives no budget for them.
  • The Secretariat must carry out many functions, but no staffing level or operating budget is stated.
  • No fees, fines, taxes or savings are specified.

What is unclear#

  • “Climate crisis” and several other key terms are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set the amount, source or timing of funding, or establish a grant application or approval process.
  • It does not set deadlines for most of the plan’s required contents, or say how the Minister will measure whether the plan is working.
  • The Secretariat’s membership, staffing, budget and oversight are not specified. Its functions are subject to direction from the Health and Environment ministers.
  • Consultation is required, but the bill does not specify how it must be done or require the Minister to accept advice from those consulted or from the science advisory board.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that health planning may need to address risks the bill identifies, such as extreme heat, infectious diseases, poor air and water quality, and disruptions to medical care.
  • A plan, monitoring systems and scientific advice could help the government identify risks and vulnerable communities before deciding how to respond.
  • Requiring the plan to cover research, infrastructure priorities, funding guidance and professional training could connect information about risks with preparation by health services.
  • Requiring consultation with affected communities and health organizations could bring their knowledge into the plan.

Case against#

  • The bill requires extensive planning and Secretariat work but does not set budgets, staffing levels or clear measures of success. The duties could therefore be difficult to carry out consistently.
  • The funding requirement is to prepare a plan for funding; it does not guarantee money for health units or facilities.
  • The Minister controls the plan, appoints the advisory board and decides which other people or organizations should be consulted. The bill does not require the Minister to follow the board’s advice.
  • The bill does not specify how the many monitoring, research and preparedness activities would be coordinated with existing work.