Summary#
Bill 226, Broadband is an Essential Service Act, 2020, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would require the Minister of Infrastructure to develop and update a broadband strategy, with targets of reaching 95 per cent of Ontarians by 2026 and all Ontarians by 2030. The Act’s stated goal is universal access to affordable and reliable high-speed internet, particularly in Northern and rural Ontario.
- The Minister must define actions, partner roles, timelines and performance measures in the strategy. “High-speed internet” means service with download speeds of at least 50 megabits per second and upload speeds of at least 10.
- The Minister must update the strategy at least every two years. Each update must report on actions taken and progress against the previous strategy’s measures.
- The Minister must consult representatives of the federal and municipal governments, Indigenous communities and the general public.
- The Minister must publish each strategy on an Ontario government website and table it in the Legislative Assembly as soon as reasonably possible.
- The targets guide the strategy; the bill does not itself require internet providers to extend service or guarantee that the targets will be met.
What it means for you#
- People without high-speed internet: The strategy must identify how many Ontarians lack access and where they are generally located. The bill does not give individuals a right to internet service or create an application process for getting connected.
- Indigenous communities, municipal and federal governments, and the public: The Minister must consult representatives of these groups while developing or updating the strategy. The bill does not specify how the consultations must work or how their input must be used.
- Internet providers and other potential partners: The strategy must describe partners’ roles, but the bill itself does not require any provider or partner to take a specific action.
- Ontario government: The Minister must develop, update, publish and table the strategy. The bill does not set rules for how particular projects would be chosen or funded.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost.
- The bill requires the Minister to prepare and update strategies, consult, publish them and table them, but it gives no estimate of the staffing or other costs.
- It does not appropriate money or set out funding for broadband projects.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not say how the strategy’s actions will be funded or who will pay for them.
- “Affordable” and “reliable” are part of the goal but are not defined. The bill defines high-speed internet by speed only.
- The bill does not explain how the Minister would ensure that the targets are met, or what happens if they are missed.
- It does not set consultation procedures or explain how Indigenous communities would be involved beyond consultation with their representatives.
- The bill does not specify how the targets would be measured or how the strategy would interact with existing broadband programs.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would require the province to identify where high-speed access is missing and set out actions and timelines to address the gaps.
- Regular updates, progress reports and performance measures could make it easier to track whether the strategy is advancing toward its targets.
- Required consultation could bring federal, municipal, Indigenous and public perspectives into the strategy.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill creates a planning and reporting duty, not a direct duty to provide service or fund projects. The targets may not be met.
- The bill does not provide funding or say who would pay to carry out the strategy’s actions.
- The bill leaves important matters—such as what counts as affordable or reliable service and how consultations must work—unclear.