Budget Act expands taxes and conservation rules

Summary#

Bill 229, Protect, Support and Recover from COVID-19 Act (Budget Measures), 2020, is an omnibus law that creates new Acts and amends or repeals many existing Acts. Its stated goal is to implement budget measures related to COVID-19; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The law received Royal Assent, but some provisions were set to start later by proclamation.

  • Conservation authorities: The Act narrows their objects to specified programs and services, sets rules for municipal funding and agreements, and expands provincial oversight. In certain cases, it requires an authority to issue a permit for a project authorized by a provincial zoning order, subject to conditions and an agreement to compensate for impacts.
  • Credit unions: It replaces the Credit Unions and Caisses Populaires Act, 1994 with a new Act. The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) gains rule-making and enforcement powers, including authority to impose administrative penalties.
  • Online lotteries and film rules: Regulations may establish a lottery subsidiary of the Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario (AGCO) to run prescribed online lottery schemes. A new film law replaces film classification with content information for many paid public screenings, and sets age rules for adult sex films and physical video games.
  • Taxes and municipal choices: The Act raises the Employer Health Tax exemption to $1 million for 2020–2028, creates a temporary seniors’ home safety tax credit for 2021, and lets municipalities change certain property-tax reductions and vacant-property rebate programs.
  • Other changes: It changes governance and reporting rules for the Ontario College of Teachers and early childhood educators; permits data disclosures from driver records for listed purposes; and changes rules for provincial parks, Crown forest operations, and other areas.
  • Public finances: It authorizes interim spending limits for two fiscal years and up to $18 billion in borrowing authority. These are legal authorizations, not evidence that the full amounts were spent or borrowed.

What it means for you#

  • Taxpayers and seniors: Eligible seniors, or qualifying relatives, could claim the 2021 home safety credit for specified home improvements: 25% of qualifying costs, up to $2,500, after certain government assistance is deducted. It does not create an ongoing credit.
  • Businesses and landlords: Eligible commercial tenants received temporary protection from certain rent-arrears evictions and property seizures during a non-enforcement period. The Act set a later repeal for these rules; they are not an ongoing protection under this temporary schedule.
  • Property owners and municipalities: A municipality may change certain tax-rate reductions or vacant-unit rebate rules by by-law. The Act does not itself require municipalities to make those changes.
  • Credit union members: The new Act sets rules for credit unions’ governance, business, capital and deposits. It also gives FSRA and its Chief Executive Officer broader regulatory and enforcement roles.
  • Researchers, developers and residents near conservation areas: A zoning order can trigger a requirement for a conservation authority to grant permission or issue a permit for certain projects outside the Greenbelt, even where ordinary conservation-authority rules might otherwise prevent it. Conditions can apply, and an agreement to address ecological and other impacts is required before work starts.
  • Film exhibitors and retailers: Paid public film exhibitors generally must provide content information or an earlier Ontario classification. Businesses dealing in adult sex films or physical video games must follow approval and age restrictions. The rules described here do not create a general age-rating requirement for all online content.
  • Driver-record information: The Registrar may disclose prescribed information to listed recipients for listed purposes, under an agreement. This is permission, not a requirement to disclose every record.

Money#

The Act authorizes interim spending and borrowing, but the available material does not give a full estimate of its net cost.

  • For 2021–22, it authorizes up to $158.06 billion for public-service expenses, $5.08 billion for investments, and $286.59 million for Legislative Office expenses, pending regular supply approval.
  • For 2020–21, it adds interim authority for up to $23.39 billion in expenses and $208.40 million in investments.
  • It authorizes borrowing of up to $18 billion. It does not say how much would be borrowed.
  • The seniors’ credit can be up to $2,500 per eligible claim, subject to the rules and limits. No total cost estimate is provided.
  • The Act requires the Ontario Northland Transportation Commission to submit a budget for ministerial approval, and it allows new staffing and administration under some schedules. No cost figures for these changes are provided.

What is unclear#

  • The materials do not say which provisions that required proclamation had started, or provide the regulations and rules needed to fill in many details.
  • The parent Acts are not supplied in full, so this summary cannot verify every change against the current consolidated law.
  • The Act does not set out a complete process for conservation-authority consultations, all permit decisions, or how ecological compensation agreements will work; some details are left to regulations.
  • It does not specify whether or how Indigenous communities will be involved in the affected conservation-authority decisions.
  • The materials do not give total costs, staffing levels, or a forecast of tax-credit claims, borrowing or actual spending.

Case for#

  • The Act gives conservation authorities clearer categories for required, municipal and other services, with agreements for some municipal funding. This could make responsibilities and costs more explicit.
  • The new credit-union law gives the sector regulator tools to set rules and respond to non-compliance, while retaining deposit insurance provisions.
  • The temporary seniors’ credit could help eligible people pay for specified changes intended to improve home access, function or safety.
  • Allowing online lottery operations through an AGCO subsidiary could provide a designated operator under AGCO oversight and ministerial direction.

Case against#

  • Conservation-authority powers over development are limited in important cases: certain zoning-order projects must receive permission or a permit, while the Minister can also direct authorities not to issue permits and issue them instead. The materials do not fully explain how this balances development with environmental protection.
  • The law gives regulators and ministers substantial powers, while leaving important rules, standards and procedures to later regulations or directives.
  • Broad changes across many policy areas make it harder to assess the combined effects and costs from the supplied material.
  • The temporary tax credit and spending authorizations do not, by themselves, show how much help people will receive or how much public money will ultimately be used.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2020120801

    Passed87 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 229

    FOR · 54AGAINST · 33

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    54For

    • PC54

    33Against

    • NDP27
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2020120802

    Passed87 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 229

    FOR · 54AGAINST · 33

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    54For

    • PC54

    33Against

    • NDP27
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2020112301

    Passed73 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 229, An Act to implement Budget measures and to enact, amend and repeal various statutes.

    FOR · 53AGAINST · 20

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    53For

    • PC53

    20Against

    • NDP13
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  4. Division No. 2020112304

    Passed81 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 229

    FOR · 57AGAINST · 24

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    57For

    • PC57

    24Against

    • NDP17
    • Liberal6
    • Green1