Bill hikes home tax, overhauls regulator

Summary#

Bill 70, the Building Ontario Up for Everyone Act (Budget Measures), 2016, enacts budget measures and amends existing laws across several policy areas. It also creates the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario Act, 2016 and repeals the laws for the Ontario Retirement Pension Plan. Its stated goal is to implement budget measures; that does not guarantee any particular result.

  • Home buyers: From January 1, 2017, the land transfer tax rate rises on the portion of a property’s value above $400,000. For a property with one or two single-family homes worth more than $2 million, an extra rate applies to the portion above $2 million. The Act also raises the maximum first-time buyer refund to $4,000 and changes eligibility rules.
  • Financial services: The Act creates a Crown-agent corporation, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA). It must prepare with the Minister to take on regulation of the regulated sectors. The law allows regulated entities to be assessed for certain preparation and regulatory costs.
  • Retirement and pensions: The Ontario Retirement Pension Plan and its administration corporation are repealed; the corporation’s assets and liabilities transfer to Ontario’s Crown. Pension law also gains new rules on annuity purchases, certain employer exemptions, and administrative penalties.
  • Trades and workplace safety: The Ontario College of Trades must develop a public compliance and enforcement policy. The Act sets up a process for classifying trades and allows administrative penalties for certain violations. It also lets the Chief Prevention Officer accredit workplace health and safety systems and recognize employers who use them; employers must apply.
  • Local government and labour: Regional municipality heads of council, except in Oxford County, must be elected by general vote starting with the 2018 election. Correctional bargaining-unit disputes in the Ontario public service must go to arbitration if conciliation fails; strikes and lockouts are prohibited for that unit.
  • Other measures: The Act changes rules on alcohol taxes, credit-union syndicated loans, tobacco enforcement, municipal property taxes, and other matters. It also authorizes interim spending, subject to stated ceilings.

What it means for you#

  • Home buyers: A purchase registered from January 1, 2017 may face higher land transfer tax, depending on the property value and type. The first-time buyer refund is limited to eligible purchasers; for agreements made after November 14, 2016, the purchaser must be a Canadian citizen or permanent resident, with an 18-month exception if they gain that status after closing.
  • Taxpayers: The Ontario Retirement Pension Plan laws are repealed. This Act does not create an Ontario retirement-plan benefit.
  • Workers in correctional services: If bargaining reaches impasse after conciliation, the dispute goes to arbitration instead of a strike or lockout. Firefighter bargaining disputes also move to arbitration under revised rules.
  • Employers and workers in compulsory trades: The College may issue a notice requiring an administrative penalty for certain violations. A recipient may seek review by the Ontario Labour Relations Board.
  • Businesses and property owners: Some municipal tax rules may change through regulations and local by-laws. Spirits bought at a distillery retail store become subject to specified taxes from July 1, 2017.
  • The public generally: The Act does not itself make the FSRA take over regulation immediately. Some provisions require a later proclamation, and some details depend on regulations.

Money#

The Act authorizes interim spending up to specified ceilings; it does not provide a full estimate of the Act’s net cost.

  • It authorizes up to $2.482 billion in additional 2016–17 public-service expenses pending supply approval.
  • For 2017–18, it authorizes up to $129.260 billion for public-service expenses, $4.644 billion for investments, and $219.450 million for Legislative Office expenses, pending supply approval. These are ceilings, not proof that all amounts were spent.
  • The FSRA may employ staff and regulated entities may be assessed for certain costs, but no cost estimate or assessment amounts are provided.
  • The land transfer tax changes may raise revenue, but no revenue estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not give a full fiscal estimate for the tax changes, FSRA preparation, staffing, or other measures.
  • The FSRA’s start date depends on proclamation; the material does not say when it will take over regulation or how the transition will work in practice.
  • Many important details, including some penalty amounts, trade-classification criteria, and municipal tax rules, depend on later regulations.
  • The supplied material does not include the consolidated parent Acts, so I could not independently verify every amendment against current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to raise additional revenue from higher-value property transfers and to increase the first-time buyer refund.
  • A possible argument for the FSRA is that a dedicated regulator could take over regulation from existing bodies; the Act provides for preparation and transfer of information.
  • The new trade-classification process and enforcement policy could make trade rules and enforcement more structured. The text requires the policy to be made public.
  • Required arbitration could provide a way to settle correctional bargaining disputes while prohibiting strikes and lockouts.

Case against#

  • Higher land transfer tax can increase the cost of buying certain homes, and the supplied material gives no estimate of how much revenue the change will raise.
  • The FSRA’s costs may be borne in part by regulated entities, but the Act does not state the amounts or how assessments will be divided.
  • Key trade-classification and penalty details depend on future regulations, leaving important practical rules unsettled in the Act.
  • A possible trade-off in mandatory arbitration is that correctional workers cannot strike and the employer cannot lock them out; the Act does not provide a strike-based bargaining option for that unit.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2016120802

    Passed91 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 70

    FOR · 51AGAINST · 40

    51For

    • Liberal51

    40Against

    • PC24
    • NDP16
  2. Division No. 2016120101

    Passed93 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 70

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 44

    49For

    • Liberal49

    44Against

    • PC27
    • NDP17
  3. Division No. 2016113001

    Passed90 members voted

    Government Notice of Motion Number 5 relating to the allocation of time of Bill 70, An Act to implement Budget measures and to enact and amend various statutes.

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 38

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    52For

    • Liberal52

    38Against

    • PC26
    • NDP12