Municipal Councils Could Adopt Ranked Ballots

Summary#

Bill 232, the Local Choice for Local Elections Act (Ranked Ballot By-Laws), 2020, would amend the City of Toronto Act, 2006 and the Municipal Act, 2001. Its stated goal is to let municipal councils choose ranked-ballot elections for their council elections, subject to public consultation and a vote by local electors.

  • Toronto, single-tier, upper-tier and lower-tier municipal councils may pass a by-law adopting ranked ballots and setting the election procedure.
  • Before voting on a by-law to adopt, amend, revise or repeal ranked ballots, a council must consult the public as required by regulations.
  • A by-law has no effect unless more than half of the electors voting on the ratification question vote in favour. Eligible voters are those who could vote in a municipal election on that day.
  • A ratified by-law may modify how any part of the Municipal Elections Act, 1996 or its regulations applies to the election.
  • Ranked ballots mean voters rank candidates by preference, with votes distributed according to those rankings and counted in rounds.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal councils: They would gain the power to propose ranked-ballot rules for their council elections. The bill does not require any municipality to adopt them.
  • Municipal electors: If a council proposes a by-law, electors would vote on whether to ratify it. The change would take effect only if more than half of those voting on the question support it; that is not a majority of all eligible electors.
  • Voters and candidates: Your ballot would change only if your municipality adopted a by-law and electors ratified it. The bill does not itself change how any election is conducted.
  • Municipalities: A ratified by-law could modify the application of provincial election rules. The bill does not set out the full counting procedure for ranked ballots.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • A ratification vote would be conducted under the Municipal Elections Act, 1996, but the bill gives no cost estimate or says who would pay for the vote.
  • The bill provides no estimate for public consultation or for municipal work to set up ranked-ballot procedures.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify the ranked-ballot counting method, including how ties would be handled.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set public consultation requirements, but those requirements are not included in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not set timelines or explain how a council would arrange the ratification vote.
  • It is unclear how ranked-ballot by-laws would interact with existing election rules in particular situations, beyond saying they may modify the application of any provision of the provincial election law or regulations.
  • The current parent Acts were not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be checked against the full current law or existing election rules.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that municipalities could choose an election method suited to local preferences rather than having one method imposed on all.
  • Requiring a public consultation before a council vote, followed by ratification by electors, gives residents a role in deciding whether the change takes effect.
  • Letting a by-law set the procedure could give municipalities room to tailor how ranked ballots are run.

Case against#

  • The bill allows a ratified by-law to modify the application of any part of the Municipal Elections Act or its regulations, but does not set limits on which rules may be changed.
  • The bill leaves important election details, such as counting and tie rules, to municipal by-laws and does not set minimum procedural standards.
  • The consultation requirements and the cost of ratification votes are not specified in the bill, leaving important parts of implementation unresolved.