Cities may adopt ranked-ballot elections

Summary#

Bill 80, the Local Choice for Local Elections Act (Ranked Ballot By-Laws), 2021, would amend the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Election Act. Its stated goal is to let municipalities choose ranked ballots for council elections, subject to a public vote approving the change.

  • Toronto and single-tier, upper-tier and lower-tier municipalities could pass a by-law adopting ranked ballots and setting the election procedure.
  • A by-law, or a change to or repeal of one, would have no effect unless more than 50% of people voting in a ratification vote approve it.
  • Before voting on a by-law or changes to it, council must consult the public according to requirements set by regulation.
  • A ratified by-law could override or modify any provision of the Municipal Elections Act, 1996 or its regulations.
  • The bill applies the Chief Electoral Officer’s existing municipal-election functions and responsibilities to what is necessary for ranked-ballot elections. It does not create a new election agency.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal voters: If council submits a ranked-ballot by-law, eligible municipal voters would vote on whether to ratify it. The by-law would pass that vote if more than half of those who vote say yes; that is not a majority of all eligible voters.
  • Voters in a municipality that adopts ranked ballots: You would rank candidates in order of preference. Votes would be distributed based on those rankings, with counting in rounds where at least one candidate is elected or eliminated each round.
  • Municipal councils and election officials: Councils could choose whether to propose ranked ballots and set the procedure, but must consult the public first. For a ratification vote, the returning officer must report the results to the clerk, who must publish them in The Ontario Gazette.
  • Local government: The bill does not require every municipality to adopt ranked ballots. It does not directly change who is eligible to vote in regular municipal elections.
  • The supplied material does not include the amended Acts, so I could not verify all details of current municipal-election law or compare the bill with every existing rule.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is included in the supplied material.

  • Municipalities would have to carry out consultation and, if council submits a by-law for ratification, administer a vote and report its results. The bill gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • The bill assigns relevant municipal-election functions to the Chief Electoral Officer but gives no estimate of any added staffing or other costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves public-consultation requirements to regulations; those requirements are not included in the supplied material.
  • It does not give detailed rules for counting ranked ballots or explain what procedures a municipal by-law must set.
  • It does not explain how ranked-ballot rules would interact with each other or with existing election rules when more than one level of municipality is involved.
  • It allows a council to submit a ratification vote but does not set a deadline for holding one.
  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so the full current-law context and any existing rules on ranked ballots could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives municipalities a choice rather than requiring one voting method across Ontario.
  • Requiring ratification gives voters a direct say before a ranked-ballot by-law takes effect.
  • Requiring public consultation before council votes could give residents an opportunity to comment on the proposal.
  • The bill defines the basic method: voters rank candidates, and counting happens in rounds. Local by-laws could set further procedures.

Case against#

  • The bill lets a ratified municipal by-law override or modify any provision of the Municipal Elections Act, 1996 and its regulations, without stating limits on which provisions may be changed.
  • The bill does not provide the consultation requirements or detailed counting rules itself, leaving important parts to later regulations and local by-laws.
  • Municipalities would have to handle consultation and any ratification vote, but the bill does not identify funding or estimate costs.
  • It is unclear how different municipal by-laws would fit together where more than one level of municipality is involved.