Summary#
The bill text gives the short title Freeing Highways 412 and 418 Act (Toll Highway Amendments), 2018. It amends the Capital Investment Plan Act, 1993 and the Highway 407 East Act, 2012. Its stated goal is to restrict toll designations on highways connecting Highway 407 East to Highway 401.
- The Ontario Transportation Capital Corporation (OTCC) could no longer use its power under the Capital Investment Plan Act to designate those connecting King’s Highways as toll highways.
- The bill would also change the definition of “Highway 407 East” to exclude those connecting highways.
- The bill’s title names Highways 412 and 418, but its operative provisions describe connecting King’s Highways rather than naming 412 or 418 directly.
- The bill would start on a date set by proclamation. It does not itself set that date.
What it means for you#
- People using Highways 412 and 418: The bill would prevent the OTCC from designating highways that meet its description as toll highways using this specific legal power. The bill does not itself set toll rates, cancel existing tolls, or require toll refunds.
- The OTCC: It would face a legal limit on its power to designate the described highways as toll highways under the Capital Investment Plan Act.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not create a new tax, fee, benefit, or public service.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not include an appropriation, cost estimate, or funding for implementation.
- No publicly available information on administrative costs or any lost toll revenue.
What is unclear#
- The Capital Investment Plan Act and Highway 407 East Act were not supplied, so the current legal and toll arrangements could not be checked against the Acts themselves.
- The bill does not say whether any existing toll designation would be cancelled. It restricts future designations using the OTCC’s specified power.
- The bill does not define what counts as a highway that “connects” Highway 407 East to Highway 401.
- The bill does not name Highways 412 and 418 in its operative provisions. How the description applies to them is not explained.
- The start date depends on a proclamation; no date is given.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent the OTCC from using this power to designate connecting highways between Highway 407 East and Highway 401 as toll highways.
- Changing the definition of Highway 407 East would separate those connecting roads from the defined highway.
- A possible argument for the bill is that it sets a clear legal limit on toll designations for these connecting routes.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill does not itself say existing tolls would end or existing designations would be removed.
- The restriction applies to the OTCC’s power under the Capital Investment Plan Act. The text does not explain whether other legal powers could be used to impose tolls.
- The bill leaves “connects” undefined, which may leave uncertainty about which roads are covered.
- The bill does not give a start date or explain how its effect on Highways 412 and 418 would be confirmed.