Summary#
Bill 83, the Freeing Highways 412 and 418 Act (Toll Highway Amendments), 2022, would amend Ontario’s Highway 407 East Act, 2012. Its stated goal is to prevent tolls on Highways 412 and 418.
- A King’s Highway, other than Highway 35/115, that connects the specified part of Highway 407 East to Highway 401 could not be designated as a toll highway. The explanatory note identifies Highways 412 and 418 as the roads covered.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council (the provincial Cabinet) could not set a toll under this Act for driving on a highway covered by that restriction.
- The bill does not remove Highway 407 East’s toll-highway designation or include Highway 35/115 in the restriction.
- The bill would take effect on a day set by proclamation. It does not give a start date.
What it means for you#
- Drivers on Highways 412 and 418: If the bill takes effect, those roads could not be designated as toll highways under this Act, and Cabinet could not set a toll under this Act for driving on them.
- Drivers on Highway 407 East: The bill does not remove that highway’s toll designation.
- Drivers on Highway 35/115: It is specifically excluded from the restriction.
- Provincial government: Cabinet would lose the power under this Act to prescribe tolls for the covered connecting highways.
- Other road users: The bill does not directly change road access, speed limits, or vehicle rules.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill provides no spending amount, staffing plan, or estimate of lost toll revenue.
- It would prevent tolls from being set under this Act for the covered highways. Whether tolls are currently charged on those roads, and any effect on revenue, is not stated.
What is unclear#
- The bill describes the affected roads by their connection between other highways rather than naming Highways 412 and 418 in its operative text. The explanatory note identifies those two highways, but the scope of the description is not further explained.
- The materials do not say whether tolls are currently charged on these roads or what revenue would be affected.
- The bill does not explain whether any other legal authority could impose a charge on these roads.
- The start date depends on a proclamation, and no date is specified.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would put a clear limit in law on tolling the connecting highways identified as Highways 412 and 418.
- The bill restricts both the designation of those roads as toll highways and Cabinet’s power to set tolls for driving on them. This could reduce uncertainty about whether tolls may be introduced under this Act.
- It leaves Highway 407 East’s toll designation in place, so the change is limited to the connecting highways described in the bill.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill would remove Cabinet’s ability under this Act to set tolls on the covered roads, without explaining why that limit is needed or how it might affect public revenue.
- The bill’s road description may leave uncertainty about exactly which highways are covered beyond those identified in the explanatory note.
- The bill does not set a start date or explain how its restrictions would interact with any other legal authority to charge for using the roads.