Summary#
Bill 27, the Burden Reduction Act, 2017, amends or repeals existing Ontario laws and creates several new laws. It was enacted as Chapter 2 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. Its stated goal is to reduce rules for businesses and save government money; those results are not guaranteed.
- Government programs: The agriculture and northern development ministers may establish programs. Agriculture program orders can set service and grant conditions, repayment rules, fees and waivers, and who may run a program. Municipal councils must appoint valuers if an agriculture program requires them.
- Courts and fines: The bill creates a Small Claims Court Administrative Judge position within the existing court system. It also requires defendants to pay certain municipal collection-agency costs on overdue fines, up to an amount approved by the municipality.
- Business and international law: It repeals the Bulk Sales Act and enacts laws implementing international conventions on court agreements, arbitration, electronic contracts, trusts and international sales.
- Regulation and utilities: It gives inspectors new powers to require answers and related records under several environmental laws. It also changes Ontario Energy Board powers and procedures, including allowing the Board to exempt some transactions from review.
- Land and public facilities: It allows occupation of public land for prescribed structures or uses without a lease or permit, subject to limits and possible orders to leave. It expands Ontario Place Corporation’s activities and lets it acquire or dispose of land, with provincial cabinet approval.
- Work, wildlife and roads: It changes rules for child performers, authorizes certain human resources professionals to conduct paid workplace investigations, and gives appointed escorts powers to direct traffic or close roads for permitted oversized vehicles.
What it means for you#
- Businesses and people involved in international contracts: The new laws set rules for matters such as enforcing certain foreign court judgments and arbitration awards, using electronic communications in international contracts, and limitation periods for international goods sales. The repeal of the Bulk Sales Act removes that Act, but the supplied material does not explain the practical effect on buyers or creditors.
- Businesses and regulated parties: Under several environmental laws, inspectors may require a person, or someone working for them, to answer reasonable inquiries and produce relevant records or data. The bill does not create a general review or application process for every business.
- Utilities and their customers: The Ontario Energy Board may act even when a court-appointed official is managing a regulated utility; that official must obey Board orders within its authority. The Board may publish inspection findings after giving the information provider a chance to comment. Some utility transactions may be exempt from Board review if they meet criteria the Board sets.
- Child performers and employers: Employers must limit work to eight hours a day, cannot require split shifts, and must provide a meal break of at least 30 minutes after no more than five consecutive work hours. Meal breaks do not count as work time; other breaks and tutoring do. Employers may also have to cover a parent or guardian’s overnight travel expenses, up to prescribed maximums.
- People who use public land: Occupation without a lease, licence or permit is allowed only for prescribed structures or uses and subject to rules and exclusions. The Minister may require the occupant to leave at any time and for any reason; the occupant must remove structures at their own expense. Occupation does not give the person ownership or an interest in the land.
- Drivers and road users: An appointed oversized-vehicle escort may direct traffic or close a highway while escorting a permitted vehicle, subject to limits. Drivers must obey directions and may not intentionally drive on a closed road, subject to listed exceptions. The bill also changes some bicycle, streetcar, railway-crossing and reporting rules.
- Hunters, trappers and fishers: The bill changes some firearm-safety rules and expands when certain trappers may hunt. The Minister may refuse a licence under the Act until an overdue fine under that Act or the federal Fisheries Act is paid.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Agriculture program orders may require participant fees, offer grants or other payments, and allow some participant expenses to be reimbursed. No amounts are set in the bill.
- Defendants must pay certain municipal collection-agency costs for overdue fines, up to the amount the municipality approves.
- Employers may have to pay eligible overnight travel, accommodation or food expenses for a child performer’s parent or guardian, up to prescribed maximums.
- The bill states a goal of government savings but gives no estimate. It provides no estimate of staffing or implementation costs.
What is unclear#
- The parent Acts were not supplied separately, so I could not independently verify every amendment against the full current law. The bill’s explanatory note describes some, but not all, prior rules.
- Several changes depend on regulations or later decisions, including agriculture program details, environmental requirements, public-land uses and oversized-vehicle escort rules. The supplied material does not give those details.
- Some provisions require a start date set by proclamation. No proclamation dates are included in the supplied material.
- The material does not quantify savings, implementation costs, fees or potential payments under the new or changed programs. No publicly available information.
- The supplied material does not explain the practical effects of repealing the Bulk Sales Act on buyers, sellers or creditors.
Case for#
- The bill may reduce administrative steps by letting ministers establish some programs directly and by changing requirements such as the number of plans a dam applicant must submit.
- Common rules for international contracts, arbitration and court judgments could make cross-border legal processes more consistent.
- Inspectors’ ability to ask questions and obtain records may help them check compliance without relying only on site visits.
- Longer forest-resource licence terms and more flexible review rules may reduce repeated administrative work.
Case against#
- The bill covers many areas, but key details are left to regulations, ministerial orders or later Board decisions. Readers cannot tell from the bill alone how some changes will work in practice.
- Some new powers have limited process details in the bill. For example, the Minister may require public-land occupants to leave at any time and for any reason, with removal costs falling on the occupant.
- The bill creates possible public costs and fees without estimating them, even as it states a government-savings goal.
- Repealing the Bulk Sales Act changes the legal rules for bulk business sales, but the supplied material does not explain what safeguards or protections may be affected.