Summary#
Bill 140, Improving Air Quality for Our Children Act, 2023, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to improve air quality in publicly funded schools and licensed child care settings by measuring carbon dioxide levels, publishing results and setting out response measures.
- Schools and licensed child care providers would have to install continuously powered carbon dioxide monitors in every classroom and congregate space, with specified sensor, display, placement and annual recalibration requirements.
- The maximum threshold would be 600 parts per million above outdoor carbon dioxide levels. The Ministry of Education would publish a target for each region each year based on that region’s outdoor levels.
- Schools and child care facilities would have to report room-level readings to the Ministry at least weekly. The Ministry would publish the reports and the raw data, with reports colour-coded by how close readings are to the threshold.
- The Ministry would have to develop an Air Quality Action Plan within 60 days after the relevant section comes into force, after consulting specified experts and education and child care groups. School boards would have to comply with the plan.
- When readings exceed the threshold, the school or child care centre would have to report to the Ministry what measures it took. The Minister may make regulations setting out responses to non-compliance, including warnings or penalties.
What it means for you#
- School boards: Must ensure schools install monitors, including in school spaces leased to or occupied by child care centres and community groups if those spaces are contiguous with the school building. Boards must also comply with the Action Plan.
- Schools and child care providers: Must install and recalibrate monitors, report readings weekly, and report measures taken when readings exceed the threshold. The bill does not itself require a particular building upgrade whenever a reading is high.
- Parents, children and the public: Could see published room-level reports and raw data. The bill also requires the Action Plan to include educational resources for parents and children and wall infographics explaining readings and possible steps.
- Teachers, education workers and child care workers: The Ministry must consult specified groups, including unions for teachers and other education workers, while preparing the plan. The bill does not give them a separate approval role.
- General public: The bill does not directly set ventilation-system standards or provide funding for upgrades. It sets monitoring and reporting duties and requires the plan to describe response measures.
Money#
No cost information is available in the supplied material.
- Schools, child care providers and boards would have costs for monitors, installation, power, recalibration and reporting work. No estimate or funding source is specified.
- The Ministry would have to prepare the plan and publish targets, reports and raw data. The bill gives no cost estimate for this work.
What is unclear#
- “Congregate space” and when carbon dioxide levels “approach” the threshold are not defined.
- The Action Plan must describe responses, but its detailed measures are not yet set out. The bill does not specify who in each setting must monitor readings or take each measure; it requires the plan to give guidance on that responsibility.
- The Minister may make regulations on non-compliance, but the bill does not itself set specific penalties or explain how compliance would be checked.
- The bill does not state how the costs would be divided among school boards, schools, child care providers and the province.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make indoor carbon dioxide levels visible, rather than relying only on ventilation upgrades. Its preamble says readings can help track ventilation-system performance.
- Weekly reporting and public results could make it easier to identify rooms with repeated high readings.
- A province-wide Action Plan, developed with technical and education input, could give schools and child care settings guidance on temporary steps and longer-term fixes.
Case against#
- The bill requires equipment, upkeep and reporting but gives no cost estimate or funding. Those costs could be difficult for schools or child care providers to meet.
- Carbon dioxide is described in the bill as a proxy for indoor air quality, not a complete measure. Readers could overinterpret a colour-coded result without further context.
- Important response details depend on a future Action Plan, and the bill does not itself set specific penalties for non-compliance.