Municipalities could set gas-emission limits

Summary#

Bill 29, the Think Twice Before You Choose Natural Gas Act (Ontario Energy Board Amendment), 2022, would amend the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998. Its stated goal is to make clear that the Act’s gas-distribution duty does not prevent municipalities from setting conditions on new residential gas connections through by-laws that limit greenhouse gas emissions.

  • Municipalities could impose conditions on a new residential connection under a by-law establishing limits on greenhouse gas emissions attributable to residential consumers in the municipality.
  • The bill would clarify that the gas distributor’s duty to provide service along its pipelines does not, by itself, prevent those municipal conditions.
  • “Greenhouse gas” would have the same meaning as in the Environmental Bill of Rights, 1993.
  • The bill does not itself ban residential gas connections or set conditions for them. Any conditions would depend on a municipal by-law.
  • If enacted, the bill would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: The bill would make clear that the gas-distribution duty in the amended Act does not block conditions on new residential connections under qualifying municipal by-laws.
  • People seeking a new residential gas connection: You might face conditions if your municipality adopts such a by-law. The bill does not set those conditions or require municipalities to adopt a by-law.
  • People with existing connections: The bill addresses new residential connections; it does not directly change existing connections.
  • Gas distributors: The bill says the duty to provide distribution service along pipeline routes does not restrict qualifying municipal conditions. The supplied material does not describe any other change to distributors’ duties.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill sets no tax, fee, fine, spending amount, or staffing requirement.
  • Any cost to municipalities of making or applying by-laws is not estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998, so the bill’s description of the current law could not be checked against the Act as a whole.
  • The bill does not explain what kinds of conditions municipalities could impose, or how those conditions would relate to the emissions limits in a by-law.
  • It does not set rules for how municipalities would make, apply, or enforce such by-laws.
  • It does not explain how municipal conditions would interact with other existing rules or programs.
  • The bill uses the definition of “greenhouse gas” in another Act, but that definition is not included in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that municipalities should be able to set local conditions aimed at limiting residential greenhouse gas emissions, even where gas pipes are already available.
  • Clarifying that the distribution duty does not block those conditions could reduce uncertainty about the relationship between provincial gas-distribution rules and municipal by-laws.
  • The bill leaves municipalities to decide whether to adopt a by-law, rather than imposing one province-wide rule on new residential connections.

Case against#

  • The bill does not spell out what conditions municipalities may impose, which could leave residents, builders, and distributors uncertain about what a qualifying by-law can require.
  • Rules could differ between municipalities, so the conditions for a new connection may depend on where a person lives.
  • The bill does not set out a process for resolving disputes about whether a municipal condition fits the bill’s limits.
  • It is unclear how municipalities would weigh emissions limits against the gas distributor’s duty to provide service.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2022120702

    Defeated106 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 29

    AGAINST · 76FOR · 30

    76Against

    • PC76

    30For

    • NDP25
    • Liberal4
    • Green1