Summary#
Bill 180, the Building a Better Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2024, became law as Chapter 12 of Ontario’s 2024 statutes. It creates the Building Ontario Fund Act, 2024 and amends other laws, including tax and pension laws. Its stated goal is to support investment in Ontario infrastructure and implement budget measures.
- It continues the Ontario Infrastructure Bank as the Building Ontario Fund, a Crown corporation, and gives it powers to invest in revenue-generating infrastructure projects and attract investment.
- It extends existing clear-fuel and gasoline tax reductions through December 31, 2024, and removes a 6.1% basic tax on Ontario wine and wine coolers bought at onsite winery retail stores.
- It authorizes the Crown to borrow up to $15.9 billion under the Ontario Loan Act, 2024.
- It changes pension-plan requirements for target benefits, including policies, conversions and information supplied to the pension regulator.
- It changes eligibility and labour-cost calculations for the Ontario Computer Animation and Special Effects Tax Credit.
- It increases some fines under the Tobacco Tax Act and creates an offence for possessing at least 100,000 unmarked cigarettes or 100,000 grams of unmarked fine-cut tobacco at a controlled location or while travelling to or from it.
What it means for you#
- Infrastructure investors and public bodies: The Fund may invest in, and seek investment for, Ontario infrastructure projects expected to generate revenue and be in the public interest. It may work with qualified institutional investors, public-sector entities, governments and Indigenous communities, with priority given to Canadian investors. The law does not require every project to receive funding.
- Building Ontario Fund: The Fund can make equity investments, loans and guarantees; structure proposals and negotiate agreements; assess unsolicited proposals; provide financing advice; and hold, sell or otherwise deal with assets. Projects must be entirely in Ontario unless the Minister approves otherwise, and the Fund cannot finance a project with an investor whose interests do not align with Ontario’s public interest. Its borrowing and financial-risk activities require a Minister-approved by-law and coordination by the Ontario Financing Authority, unless the Minister directs someone else to do that work. A guarantee under $200 million does not need the Minister’s approval; a larger one does.
- Fuel and gasoline buyers: The existing tax reductions were extended to December 31, 2024. The supplied material does not state the reduction amount.
- Winery customers: The basic tax on Ontario wine and wine coolers bought at an onsite winery retail store was removed. Amounts paid on or after April 1, 2024, before Royal Assent, are treated as part of the purchase price, not as tax.
- Pension-plan administrators and members: The changes require written policies for plans with target benefits, and require funding and governance policies for plans without them. Administrators must consult certain member-representing associations as well as unions on proposed conversions. For target-benefit plans, the Chief Executive Officer may require information to check whether a report’s provision for adverse deviations complies with the law.
- Film and television producers: The tax credit’s eligibility tests distinguish productions with labour costs incurred before March 26, 2024, from those without. The latter must meet specified content, distribution and labour-cost tests; many types of content are excluded.
- People convicted of tobacco-tax offences: Some fines increase. A new offence covers possession of the stated large quantities of unmarked tobacco at a place the person controls, or in transit to or from it. It carries a $10,000–$100,000 fine, an additional fine of at least five times the applicable tax, and up to two years in prison.
Money#
No publicly available information on total fiscal costs or savings is included in the supplied material.
- The Crown is authorized to borrow up to $15.9 billion to meet Ontario’s debts or make payments authorized by law. This is borrowing authority, not a $15.9 billion spending appropriation.
- The Fund may receive advances from the Consolidated Revenue Fund, and the Minister may lend it money. The law gives no amount or cost estimate.
- The wine-tax repeal and fuel and gasoline tax reductions affect tax revenue; the materials give no revenue estimate. The Fund may hire or engage staff, but no staffing number or cost is given.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out how the Fund will choose projects, assess public interest, involve Indigenous communities, or resolve overlap with other infrastructure programs.
- The Fund’s detailed investment rules may be set by regulations, Ministerial policies or directives, or agreements; their content is not in the supplied material.
- The supplied material does not give the fuel and gasoline tax reduction amount or estimate the effects of the tax-credit changes.
- Some pension provisions have delayed commencement, and one further pension-policy provision requires proclamation. The supplied material does not establish when all pension changes take effect.
- The underlying provisions of the Tobacco Tax Act that define the conduct in the existing offences are not supplied, so the full scope of those offences cannot be verified here.
Case for#
- The Fund is designed to help bring public and private investment together for infrastructure projects that generate revenue and are in the public interest.
- Its powers to make different kinds of investments and provide financing advice could give projects another way to seek financing.
- The pension changes set policy and consultation requirements and allow the regulator to request information about target-benefit plans.
- The tobacco amendments set higher fines and a specific offence for possession of very large quantities of unmarked tobacco.
Case against#
- The Fund receives broad investment and financial powers, while the bill leaves important project-selection details to later rules, directions and decisions.
- Public accountability measures include reports and audits, but the bill does not set project-by-project approval or public consultation requirements.
- The Fund may require public advances or loans, and the Crown may have to pay certain unpaid judgments against it. The bill does not estimate those risks or costs.
- The film-credit rules use detailed content exclusions and thresholds; the supplied material does not explain how borderline productions will be assessed.