Summary#
Bill 219, the No Free Ride for Fossil Fuels Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Municipal Act, 2001 and City of Toronto Act, 2006. It would give municipalities and local boards, including Toronto and its local boards, express power to charge certain gas-sector businesses for specified services, activities, costs, or use of property. The title frames the goal as ending a “free ride”; the bill does not require any particular fee or result.
- Municipalities and local boards may charge a producer, gas distributor, gas transmitter, or storage company, as defined in the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998.
- The charge must relate to wires, cables, poles, conduits, pipes, equipment, machinery, or other works located or to be located on a municipal highway and used in the business of one of those companies.
- Regulations could not impose conditions or limits on this specific fee-setting power.
- The bill says it would come into force on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities and local boards: They would have express authority to impose these fees or charges, but would not have to do so.
- Gas-sector businesses: The listed businesses could be charged for the specified services, activities, costs, or use of property. The bill does not set a fee amount.
- Residents and customers: The bill does not directly impose a charge on residents or require companies to pass fees on to customers. Whether a company might pass on costs is not addressed.
- General public: The bill does not ban fossil fuels or require companies to remove or transfer property.
Money#
No cost estimate or revenue forecast is included in the supplied material.
- The bill does not appropriate money or require a municipality to impose a fee.
- Municipalities could collect revenue if they use this power, but the amount is unknown.
- No estimate is given for administrative or other costs to municipalities, local boards, or businesses.
What is unclear#
- The Municipal Act, 2001, the City of Toronto Act, 2006, and the referenced definitions in the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998 were not supplied, so the existing law and how these amendments fit with it could not be verified.
- The bill does not set fee rates, explain how charges would be calculated, or create a process for setting or disputing them.
- It is unclear what limits, if any, other than the restriction on regulation-making, would apply to fees imposed under this power.
- The bill does not explain whether or how fees could affect customer bills, or how municipalities would use any revenue.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that municipalities should be able to charge specified businesses for municipal services, costs, or use of property linked to infrastructure on municipal highways.
- The bill expressly covers a range of infrastructure, including pipes, poles, cables, and equipment, rather than leaving the authority unclear for those items.
- Preventing regulations from limiting this specific power could give municipalities more control over whether and how to use it.
Case against#
- The bill does not set rates or a common method for calculating charges, so fees could differ among municipalities.
- It bars regulations from placing conditions or limits on the specific power, while the bill itself does not explain what other safeguards would guide fee-setting.
- It is unclear whether companies might pass charges on to customers or what costs municipalities would incur to administer them.