Data centers barred from confidential deals

Summary#

SB-318, Data Center Non Disclosure Amendments, failed and did not take effect. It would have added new sections to Utah law covering state agencies, cities, towns, and counties; its stated goal was to prohibit certain confidentiality agreements with prospective data centers.

  • The ban would cover agreements entered into on or after the bill’s effective date with a proposed data center that has a connected electrical load of at least 20 megawatts and is seeking or awaiting approvals from that government.
  • A covered agreement would include a written or oral understanding that makes the agreement or its terms confidential, or restricts the government or its agent from discussing information related to the project.
  • Any prohibited confidentiality provision would be void and unenforceable, but the rest of a contract would remain enforceable where possible.
  • The relevant government would have to post the contract or agreement on its website within 30 days after entering it or after a court rules it violates the bill, and keep it posted for at least five years.
  • Residents could ask a district court to declare an agreement void, stop its enforcement, or require the government to post it.

What it means for you#

  • State and local governments: If the bill had become law, agencies and local governments could not have entered covered agreements, and would have had to publicly post agreements that violated the ban.
  • Data-center companies: The bill would not have banned data centers or stopped them from seeking permits. But it would have barred them from entering covered confidentiality agreements with the relevant government.
  • Residents: A resident could have taken the listed court actions against a covered agreement or to compel required posting.
  • Everyone else: The bill would not have required governments to disclose all information about data centers—its posting requirement concerned contracts or agreements that violated the ban. It also would not have changed data-center approval rules in the text provided.
  • Because the bill failed, these proposed duties and rights did not take effect.

Money#

The bill appropriated no money; no cost estimate is provided.

  • Posting contracts and handling related work could require staff time from state agencies and local governments. No publicly available information gives the cost or staffing needed.
  • The bill created no fee, fine, or direct payment to residents.

What is unclear#

  • The current Utah laws that would apply to these agreements are not included in the supplied material, so it is not possible to verify how the bill would have changed or overlapped with existing rules.
  • The bill does not explain how governments would determine a facility’s connected electrical load or whether it meets the 20-megawatt threshold.
  • It does not describe exceptions for information that may be confidential under other laws, or explain how the posting duty would interact with those laws.
  • It sets no process for identifying covered agreements before they are signed, and no penalty is stated for a government that enters one. Residents could seek court orders, but the bill does not set out further court procedures.
  • The text sets May 6, 2026, as the proposed effective date, but the bill failed.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the public should be able to see agreements made by governments while a large data center is seeking approvals.
  • Allowing residents to ask a court to enforce the posting requirement could provide a way to challenge secrecy without relying only on government action.
  • Voiding the confidentiality provision while preserving the rest of a contract could limit disruption to other contract terms.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the definition could reach any written or oral agreement with a confidentiality term, even if that term covers information beyond the data center project.
  • Posting a contract could reveal commercially sensitive information; the bill does not describe a process for handling information protected by other laws.
  • The bill does not specify how officials should assess the 20-megawatt threshold or resolve borderline cases, which could make it harder to know when the ban applies.