City to study data-centre impacts

Summary#

On July 28, 2026, Council unanimously approved the recommendations and actions from the committee meeting on “Addressing the Risks of Digital Infrastructure.” But the only detailed motion provided was marked lost at that committee meeting, and the materials do not show a separate final Council motion. So it is unclear whether Council adopted the detailed directions below.

  • Councillor Maloney’s motion would have directed staff to report on a proposed public-impact assessment for data centres, covering water use, emissions, noise, heat, air contaminants, heat recovery and employment impacts.
  • It would also have asked staff to report on checking data-centre applications against City goals, reviewing impacts from existing or retrofitted facilities, and whether the Noise Control By-law needs changes.
  • Other proposed reports covered enforcement options, annual public reporting of water, power and noise, and ways to secure public benefits.
  • The motion sought reports on these issues before specified Telus data-centre decisions concerning 111 East 5th Avenue and 150 West Georgia Street.

What it means for you#

  • Residents and businesses: The materials do not confirm that Council adopted the detailed motion. They therefore do not establish a new assessment, noise rule, reporting duty or enforcement process.
  • Applicants for data centres: The detailed motion did not itself require applicants to complete assessments or disclose resource use. It would have asked staff to report on how such requirements could be developed and enforced.
  • City staff: The motion would have directed staff to prepare several reports. Because the motion is recorded as lost at committee and no final Council wording is supplied, the materials do not confirm those duties.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The proposed reports and review would require staff work, but no staffing or cost estimate is provided.
  • The motion asked staff to explore third-party assessments and possible public-benefit contributions; it did not set a fee or contribution amount.

What is unclear#

  • Did Council’s July 28 approval include Maloney’s detailed motion, despite the committee record showing it was lost?
  • What exact wording did Council approve? No separate final motion is supplied.
  • If the proposed reports were approved, when would they be due, and what staff resources would they require?
  • The proposed assessment and enforcement requirements were not fully designed: details such as how assessments would be conducted and what consequences would apply were left for staff to report on.

Case for#

  • The motion’s stated concern was that data centres may affect water use, emissions, noise, heat and nearby infrastructure. It proposed studying those impacts before further approvals.
  • It also proposed comparing employment impacts with other possible industrial uses of the land, and checking projects against City goals.
  • Twenty-one speakers supported the motion at the committee meeting.

Case against#

  • The motion called for reports and options, not an immediate assessment or enforcement system. If Council intended prompt safeguards before the named Telus decisions, the proposed reporting approach might not itself provide them.
  • The motion did not set the assessment rules, enforcement consequences, or public-benefit amount; those details would have depended on later staff work and decisions.
  • The supplied record does not explain how Council’s approval relates to the committee’s recorded loss of the detailed motion, leaving the practical effect uncertain.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 11790

    Defeated10 members voted

    Standing Committee on City Finance and Services: Motion 5. Addressing the Risks of Digital Infrastructure

    AGAINST · 7FOR · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7Against

    • ABC Vancouver7

    3For

    • COPE1
    • OneCity Vancouver1
    • Vote Vancouver1