Surveillance Data Couldn’t Set Custom Prices

Summary#

HB 121 would amend the Virginia Consumer Protection Act and add a new chapter to the Code of Virginia. It would prohibit certain customized prices based on consumer data collected through electronic surveillance technology; the bill’s stated goal is not specified beyond that prohibition.

  • Suppliers could not set a price for a specific consumer or group based in whole or in part on consumer data gathered through electronic surveillance technology.
  • The ban would not cover price differences based solely on the cost of serving different consumers, or discounts offered under the bill’s listed conditions, such as publicly disclosed eligibility rules or a loyalty program.
  • A discount could also be offered after a consumer knowingly provides specific personal data for that purpose, if the reason for collecting it is explained clearly and prominently.
  • A violation would count as a prohibited practice under the Consumer Protection Act and be subject to that Act’s enforcement provisions.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: A supplier could not use data gathered through surveillance technology to set a customized price for you, unless an exception applies. The bill does not ban all different prices or discounts.
  • Consumers: If you knowingly provide specific personal data to get a discount, the supplier must clearly and prominently explain the nature and purpose of that data disclosure.
  • Suppliers: You would have to avoid pricing based on covered surveillance data or fit the price difference within one of the listed exceptions.
  • General public: The bill creates a new chapter, not a new agency or front-line service. The supplied materials do not include the current Consumer Protection Act, so I could not verify the full scope of its existing rules or enforcement powers.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied materials.

  • The bill sets no new fee or specific civil-penalty amount. It makes violations subject to the Consumer Protection Act’s enforcement provisions; the supplied materials do not establish what those provisions currently authorize.
  • Suppliers may face costs to check whether their pricing practices comply. The bill gives no estimate of those costs or of any government enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • “Electronic surveillance technology” is defined broadly, but the bill does not explain how its definition would apply to particular data or pricing systems.
  • The bill does not set out how a consumer or supplier would establish that a price was based on covered data.
  • The bill does not specify an effective date, investigation process, or other details for applying the ban.
  • The current text of the Consumer Protection Act was not supplied. I could not verify the existing enforcement provisions or compare the bill’s rewritten text of the Act’s prohibited-practices section with current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent prices from being customized using data about a consumer’s behavior, location, or other personal attributes gathered through surveillance technology.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it targets a particular source of price differences while preserving stated exceptions for cost differences and disclosed discounts.
  • Requiring clear notice when someone provides personal data for a discount could help consumers understand why the data is being collected.

Case against#

  • The terms used to describe surveillance technology and customized prices may leave suppliers and consumers uncertain about which pricing practices are covered.
  • The bill does not explain how the ban would be enforced in practice or how a consumer could show that surveillance data affected a price.
  • The exceptions could make the boundary between prohibited pricing and permitted discounts difficult to apply, especially where a price difference has more than one basis.
  • The bill does not state the penalty amount or the likely costs of compliance and enforcement.