National popular vote pact would govern electors

Summary#

Wisconsin SB 1117 would have joined the state to the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote. It amends Wisconsin election statutes and creates new provisions; its stated goal is to appoint presidential electors based on the national popular vote when the agreement is active. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Wisconsin would appoint the elector slate associated with the national popular vote winner, rather than the slate associated with the winner of Wisconsin’s vote, but only if participating states together held a majority of electoral votes on July 20 of that election year.
  • The chief election official in each member state would have to total votes for each presidential ticket across the states and District of Columbia, using official state vote counts. The official would also have to release vote counts as they are determined.
  • Wisconsin’s election officials would have to certify the required electors. If the national vote is tied, Wisconsin would certify the elector slate associated with the ticket that won Wisconsin.
  • A member state could withdraw, but a withdrawal within six months or less of a president’s term ending would not take effect until a president or vice president qualified to serve the next term.

What it means for you#

  • Wisconsin voters: You would still vote for president and vice president. If the agreement governed that election, Wisconsin’s electors could be appointed for the national winner even if that ticket did not win Wisconsin.
  • Wisconsin election officials: The bill would assign duties to the state’s chief election official and elector-certifying official. It does not name those officials in the agreement; it defines them by their existing authority.
  • Governor: The governor would have to notify other states when Wisconsin joined, when the agreement took effect, or when Wisconsin withdrew. The governor would also have to notify the Legislative Reference Bureau.
  • Everyone: The agreement would not govern an election unless it was in effect in states holding a majority of electoral votes on July 20. The supplied status says the bill failed and is not law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns vote-counting, certification, and notification duties, but gives no cost estimate or staffing estimate.
  • It makes no appropriation and does not set a fee or tax.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out a process for handling disputed or inconsistent vote counts among states, or for recounts and challenges under the agreement.
  • It does not explain how different state vote-counting procedures would be reconciled beyond requiring officials to use official state statements.
  • The parent Wisconsin statutes are not supplied, so the existing law and the full extent of the changes to current procedures cannot be independently checked against their text. The bill’s analysis says Wisconsin currently awards electors based on the state’s result.
  • The bill does not estimate the staff or resources needed to carry out the new duties.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make the presidential winner reflect the total popular vote across the states and District of Columbia, rather than which ticket wins enough separate state contests.
  • It keeps elections and vote counts with state officials; it does not create a national election office.
  • The majority-of-electoral-votes condition means the agreement would not govern until enough states had joined for it to determine the electoral outcome.

Case against#

  • If the agreement were active, Wisconsin could have to appoint electors for a ticket that lost the Wisconsin vote. A possible concern is that this changes the effect of Wisconsin’s statewide result on elector selection.
  • The agreement relies on state officials’ vote totals and says their official statements are conclusive for the compact’s calculation. It does not spell out a process for resolving disputes over those totals.
  • The bill does not specify the staff or funding for the new counting and certification duties.