Legislature could sue over federal acts

Summary#

HB-333, “Federal acts-legal actions authorized-2,” would amend Wyoming Statutes section 28-8-114, an existing law on legislative legal actions. Its stated goal is to protect the legislature’s interests and help ensure proper interpretation and administration of federal acts. The bill failed, so it did not take effect; its proposed effective date was July 1, 2025.

  • It would expressly authorize the legislature to bring lawsuits seeking a declaratory judgment (a court ruling on what the law means) in state or federal court over the constitution, statutes, administrative rules, or federal acts—including federal purchases of land in Wyoming.
  • The bill says the legislature would have standing (the legal right to bring a case) to bring those actions. It names the National Environmental Policy Act, Federal Land Policy and Management Act, National Historic Preservation Act, Endangered Species Act, Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, and other federal acts.
  • When the legislature is in session, both houses could authorize an action by majority vote. During the interim, the Management Council could authorize one by majority vote. The council could also start an action on its own motion.
  • The legislature or council could direct the Legislative Service Office’s legal staff to handle a case or hire private counsel.
  • The council could use up to $75 million at a time, or the amount available, for the authorized actions.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming residents: The bill would not directly change your personal rights, duties, taxes, or access to services. Lawsuits could concern federal land plans or the listed federal acts, but the bill does not determine how any case would end.
  • Wyoming taxpayers: The bill would appropriate $75 million from the state general fund for litigation, available through June 30, 2028.
  • Legislators and the Management Council: They would have authority to authorize or start the specified cases and use state legislative legal staff or private lawyers. The bill permits lawsuits; it does not require any particular lawsuit to be filed.

Money#

The bill would appropriate $75 million from the general fund for legislative litigation; no cost estimate is provided.

  • The appropriation would go to the Legislative Service Office and could not be used for another purpose.
  • Any funds left unspent and unobligated would revert as provided by law on June 30, 2028.
  • The council’s authority to use funds would be capped at $75 million at any one time, or the amount available. The bill does not estimate legal fees or staffing costs.

What is unclear#

  • The existing version of section 28-8-114 was not supplied, so the bill’s exact change from current law could not be verified.
  • The bill says the legislature “shall have standing,” but does not establish whether a court would accept that claim in a particular case.
  • It does not set rules for choosing cases, require public reporting, or explain how litigation costs would be tracked.
  • Terms such as “necessary or advisable” and “proper interpretation or administration” are not defined in the supplied text.
  • It is unclear how this authority would interact with lawsuits or other processes already available to the state.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let the legislature ask courts to resolve disputes about federal laws and federal land decisions that it says affect the state.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that declaratory judgments can clarify legal questions without the bill itself dictating how a court must rule.
  • The bill gives elected lawmakers, or the Management Council between sessions, authority to decide whether to bring a case and who will handle it.

Case against#

  • One concern is the size of the appropriation: the bill sets aside $75 million without a cost estimate or a limit on the number of cases.
  • The bill gives broad grounds for litigation, including “other federal acts,” without explaining how cases would be selected or what oversight would apply.
  • It is unclear whether courts would accept the bill’s statement that the legislature has standing, so the state could spend money litigating a case before that question is resolved.
  • The bill permits lawsuits but does not require them; the text does not explain how the legislature would decide when litigation is worth the public cost.