Gas certification expands energy policy changes

Summary#

SB 308, titled Utility & Energy Changes, would amend New Mexico’s Renewable Portfolio Standard law and add sections to the Environmental Improvement Act and the Corporate Income and Franchise Tax Act. It would let utilities seek waivers from renewable and zero-carbon requirements, create a voluntary natural-gas certification program, and offer a tax credit for certain emissions-reducing technology. Its stated goals include supporting greenhouse-gas reductions and reliable electricity; those results are not guaranteed. The supplied status says the bill was introduced and then postponed indefinitely, so it is not law.

  • A public utility could petition the Public Regulation Commission for a waiver if meeting the standards would cause residential rate increases above 0.5% while maintaining the same level of reliability. A waiver would allow carbon-based generation, including operation for the facility’s useful life, and could allow out-of-state carbon-based electricity purchases for the contract term.
  • The Environment Department would establish a voluntary program for oil and gas operators seeking to market gas as “certified New Mexico low-emission gas.” Operators could not use that certification unless enrolled.
  • The Environmental Improvement Board would have to set measurement, reporting and verification rules, collect at least one year of program data, and then adopt a carbon-intensity standard for New Mexico natural gas production. Certification would last up to one year and require annual renewal.
  • Utilities, electric generation resources and qualified microgrids could use certified gas, but would not have to buy it. The Public Regulation Commission would allow utilities to include it in a resource portfolio or fuel plan if the purchase is otherwise reasonable and prudent.
  • A taxpayer that installs qualifying natural-gas emissions-reducing technology could claim a credit equal to 15% of eligible equipment and software purchase costs, subject to the rules in the bill.

What it means for you#

  • Electricity customers: A utility could seek permission to rely on carbon-based electricity under the waiver condition. The bill does not itself raise or lower rates, or guarantee that the commission will grant a waiver.
  • Utilities and electricity providers: They could voluntarily procure and use certified gas. The bill does not require them to do so.
  • Oil and gas operators: Participation in the certification program would be voluntary. Operators seeking certification would have to meet the standard, provide updated monitoring data and renew annually.
  • Taxpayers and businesses: A taxpayer installing qualifying technology could apply for the credit. Any unused credit could not be refunded or carried forward to another tax year.
  • General public: The bill would assign new rulemaking and program work to state agencies, but does not create a new independent agency or a general requirement for all gas production to meet the certification standard.

Money#

The bill requires agency work and authorizes a tax credit, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The credit would be 15% of eligible equipment and software costs, including software licenses. The bill sets no overall credit cap.
  • The Environment Department would process eligibility applications; the bill does not estimate the cost of this work or of the monitoring program, data collection, rules or required technical report.
  • The credit would reduce corporate income tax revenue when claimed. Its actual annual cost is unknown.
  • A utility waiver could affect generation and energy-purchase costs, but the bill does not estimate those costs or their effect on customer bills.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended laws were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the renewable-standard text restates current law and how much changes it.
  • The bill does not set the carbon-intensity limits or explain how the Board must decide whether an operator qualifies beyond requiring rules and a standard.
  • It does not spell out how the commission would decide a waiver petition, or what evidence would establish the required rate increase and reliability condition.
  • “Qualified microgrid” is not defined in the supplied text. The technology definition is broad, and the bill does not explain how the Environment Department would assess each type of equipment or practice.
  • The bill does not estimate the number of credit claims or say whether other programs may overlap with the credit.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the waiver is that it gives the commission a way to respond if meeting the standards would raise residential rates above the stated threshold while maintaining reliability.
  • Measurement-based monitoring and third-party audits, if required by the Board’s rules, could give buyers and the public more information about emissions from gas production.
  • Annual renewal and updated data could make certification depend on ongoing performance rather than a one-time claim.
  • The tax credit could help reduce the cost to businesses of installing equipment or software that qualifies as emissions-reducing technology.

Case against#

  • A waiver could allow a utility to keep operating carbon-based generation for the facility’s entire useful life, potentially weakening the effect of the renewable and zero-carbon requirements.
  • The bill does not set the carbon-intensity standard or many certification details. The Board’s future rules would determine how strict and verifiable the program is.
  • The credit would use public tax revenue, but the bill sets no cap and provides no cost estimate. It also gives no refund or carry-forward for unused credits.
  • The bill does not provide a detailed process for waiver decisions or explain how the new gas program would interact with existing monitoring and reporting requirements.