Data centers face moratorium, study required

Summary#

The Datacenter Transparency Act would create a temporary permit moratorium and a study, and amend North Carolina’s sales-and-use-tax law to require certificates and reporting for certain data-center tax exemptions. Its stated goal is to give the General Assembly time to assess data centers’ impacts; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The supplied status says the bill is introduced, so it is not law.

  • From August 1, 2026, through August 1, 2028, state agencies and local governments could not issue permits, certifications, or approvals needed to site a data center designed for a load of at least 100 megawatts.
  • The North Carolina Collaboratory at UNC-Chapel Hill must study effects on electricity demand and rates, water, wastewater, air quality, noise, and nearby property values, and report findings and any recommended legislation by December 1, 2027.
  • Data centers claiming specified existing sales-tax exemptions would need annual exemption certificates and would have to report ownership and location, local benefits and incentives, employee numbers and average wages, start-up costs, and itemized spending on listed categories such as IT, power, cooling, utilities, and services.
  • A data center that has not started construction could apply for a conditional certificate. If it fails to provide the required information, it would owe the taxes it avoided, with interest from the purchase date.
  • Existing data centers that were sited or under construction when the act takes effect and claimed an exemption would have to provide information for their five most recent years of claims. The Department of Commerce must estimate the state revenue impact and report annually to legislative finance committee chairs.

What it means for you#

  • Data centers and developers: During the moratorium period, state and local governments could not issue the listed siting approvals for facilities meeting the bill’s 100-megawatt threshold. The bill does not say that every other activity related to a project must stop.
  • Data centers claiming exemptions: Starting July 1, 2027, a data center buying an item already exempt under the cited tax law would need a certificate to claim that exemption. Certificates last for one taxable year and must be renewed annually. The bill does not create the underlying sales-tax exemptions.
  • State and local governments: The Collaboratory must work with the Utilities Commission, Public Staff, Department of Environmental Quality, League of Municipalities, and Association of County Commissioners on parts of the study.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The bill requires an estimate of state revenue lost through the specified exemptions. It does not change tax rates or promise that the study will lead to any particular policy.

Money#

The bill appropriates $200,000 in one-time General Fund money for the Collaboratory’s study; no total cost estimate is provided.

  • The bill does not estimate the costs of collecting and reviewing data, issuing certificates, or producing the Commerce Department’s reports.
  • It requires data centers to provide detailed information, but does not estimate their reporting costs.
  • The Commerce Department must estimate past state revenue impacts from the exemptions; the bill itself gives no estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the tax law being amended was not supplied, so I could not verify which facilities and purchases currently qualify for the referenced exemptions or how much of the certificate requirement is new.
  • The bill uses different definitions for the moratorium and the tax certificates. The tax section relies on definitions in another statute that was not supplied.
  • The bill does not explain how agencies should handle permits already issued, or applications pending, when the moratorium begins. It also does not state what happens if the bill becomes law after August 1, 2026.
  • It does not set out data-review rules, privacy protections, or a process for disputing a certificate decision. No publicly available information is supplied here about those details.
  • The bill does not explain how the study’s findings or Commerce’s revenue estimates would affect later policy.

Case for#

  • A pause on new siting approvals could give lawmakers time to examine possible effects on the electric grid, utility rates, water, wastewater, air quality, noise, and property values before more approvals are issued.
  • The study is directed to examine impacts in other states as well as in North Carolina.
  • Annual certificates and detailed spending and employment information could give lawmakers and the public more information about who receives the tax exemptions and their reported local benefits.
  • The required revenue estimate could help lawmakers assess the state’s tax expenditure (revenue forgone through an exemption).

Case against#

  • The moratorium covers siting approvals from state and local governments, with no exceptions stated for individual projects. It could delay projects even before the study is complete.
  • The bill requires extensive reporting from data centers but does not specify review standards, privacy safeguards, or how the information will be checked.
  • It is unclear how the certificate requirement will interact with existing tax rules, because the bill’s referenced definitions and current law were not supplied.
  • The study and reporting requirements have a stated appropriation for the study, but the bill does not estimate other government or business costs.