Summary#
Bill 165, the Personal Injury and Accident Victims Protection Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Law Society Act and Solicitors Act. Its stated goal is to protect clients with personal injury claims through rules on referrals, advertising and legal fees.
- The Law Society of Upper Canada would have to review ads offering legal representation for personal injury claims and approve those that meet the bill’s standards.
- Law Society licensees could not pay or accept referral fees for personal injury claims. They could not refer a client to another licensee without the client’s express written consent, and they would have to keep the client’s information confidential except as the consent allows.
- A solicitor’s fee agreement would have to explain clearly and prominently how the fee is calculated. A client could cancel a contingency fee agreement within 10 days, without giving a reason.
- For a contingency fee agreement based on a percentage of damages recovered for bodily injury or death, total compensation paid to the solicitor—including other fees—could not exceed 25% of the amount or value recovered. The solicitor would have to reimburse any excess.
- A person who contravenes the specified referral or advertising rules could be fined up to $100,000 on conviction.
What it means for you#
- People with personal injury claims: A lawyer could not arrange a referral to another licensee without your express written consent. If you enter a contingency fee agreement, you could cancel it within 10 days. The 25% cap would apply only to the kind of contingency agreement described above, not to every legal fee arrangement.
- Law Society licensees and solicitors: They would have to follow the referral and confidentiality rules, and submit covered ads for approval before advertising. Fee agreements would need clear, prominent explanations of how fees are calculated.
- The Law Society of Upper Canada: It would review the submitted ads. It would have to approve ads that meet the professional-conduct rules and do not contain false or misleading awards, testimonials or statements.
- The general public: The bill does not create a new independent organization, a general compensation benefit, or a ban on personal injury advertising. It would add rules and penalties for specified conduct.
Money#
No publicly available information gives an estimate of the bill’s administrative or enforcement costs.
- The Society would have to review submitted ads, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- The bill sets a fine of up to $100,000 on conviction; it does not make that amount an automatic charge.
- The 25% limit could require a solicitor to reimburse a client if the solicitor received more than the limit. The bill does not estimate how often that might happen.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set timelines or describe a detailed process for ad submissions, reviews or appeals.
- It does not explain how the 25% limit would treat particular charges or expenses beyond saying that other fees charged by the solicitor count toward the cap.
- The supplied material does not include the full existing Acts, so the bill’s changes cannot be checked against all current rules or possible overlap.
- The text says it would take effect on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether it received Royal Assent or is now law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make legal fees easier to understand before a client agrees to them.
- A client’s written consent and the confidentiality rule could help protect client choice and information during referrals.
- Requiring ad approval could help prevent misleading claims about awards or testimonials.
- A 25% cap could limit the portion of certain personal injury recoveries paid to a solicitor.
Case against#
- A fixed cap may not fit every case covered by the rule; the bill does not explain how different circumstances would be handled.
- The bill does not spell out the ad-review process or its timelines, leaving practical details to the Society’s rules.
- It is unclear how the cap would apply to particular fees or expenses, which could make the limit harder for clients and solicitors to understand.
- The Society would take on an ad-review duty, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detail about the resources needed.