Summary#
Bill 150, the Planning Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023, is enacted law. It creates the Official Plan Adjustments Act, 2023 and amends Ontario’s Planning Act; its stated purpose is to make specified official-plan approvals and decisions legally effective while limiting related legal claims.
- For 13 official plans or amendments adopted by named municipalities or regions, the Act treats specified ministerial decisions as never made and treats the plans as approved on the dates of those decisions. Some plans are approved as adopted; others are approved with listed modifications, including additional changes to plans for York Region, Guelph and Wellington County.
- Municipal decisions, by-laws and public works made on or after an approval’s deemed date must conform to the approved plan while it remains in effect. The plans can still be changed or repealed under the Planning Act.
- The Act bars many claims for costs, compensation or damages related to the listed decisions and plans. It also bars related court, administrative and arbitration proceedings, including claims for injunctions or declarations. The bar is retrospective.
- The Planning Act amendment adds similar limits on claims and proceedings related to decisions about the Minister’s use of powers under section 47. The supplied material describes that section as letting the Minister exercise powers given to municipal councils; the amendment does not itself add those powers.
- Judicial review is excluded from the specific bar on bringing proceedings. The Act also says the changes do not invalidate existing building permits or count as expropriation or injurious affection.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities and the Ontario Land Tribunal: Decisions made on or after the relevant deemed approval dates, and municipal by-laws and public works, must conform to the approved plans while they are in effect.
- People affected by the listed plans: The plans are legally treated as approved on the dates set out in the Act, with the specified modifications. The Act does not set out a new application or review process for affected people.
- People considering legal claims: Many claims for compensation or other remedies related to the listed plan decisions, and to decisions under Planning Act section 47, are barred. This includes claims tied to conduct or representations by named provincial and municipal officials and agents. The bar applies even to claims said to have arisen before the law took effect. Judicial review is excluded from the proceedings bar, but the text does not fully explain what relief may remain available.
- Existing building-permit holders: The Act says it does not invalidate a permit under the Building Code Act, 1992.
- General public: The Act does not directly change taxes, create a new public service, or require anyone to transfer land.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill gives no estimate of public spending, staffing costs, or savings.
- It bars certain compensation and damages claims, including claims for lost revenue or profit; the material does not estimate the financial effect.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the full Planning Act, so the existing rules and process for section 47 decisions cannot be verified here.
- The text does not explain how affected residents, landowners or municipalities were consulted about the specified plan changes.
- It does not give details on how courts will treat judicial-review applications alongside the other limits on remedies.
- It does not estimate the cost of implementing the changes or the value of claims that may be barred.
Case for#
- The bill gives legal effect to specified plan approvals and modifications, which could make the applicable planning rules clearer for municipalities and others.
- Requiring later municipal decisions, by-laws and public works to conform to the approved plans links local action to those plans.
- A possible argument for limiting related claims is that it reduces the risk of legal disputes over the listed decisions. The bill does not provide evidence about how many disputes or costs this would prevent.
Case against#
- The approvals take effect on dates in the past, and the Act also applies its limits on claims to causes of action said to have arisen before it took effect. That can change the legal position after decisions or conduct have already occurred.
- The limits bar many routes to compensation or other remedies, including claims involving loss of revenue or profit. This may leave affected people with fewer ways to seek redress.
- The Act covers claims related to a wide range of conduct and representations by current or former provincial officials and, for the listed plans, municipal officials. The text does not explain how close the connection to a decision must be for the bar to apply.
- The bill does not set out a process for affected people to seek changes to the approved plans through this Act.