Roundabouts Safety Study Bill

Summary#

Bill 72, the Safe Roundabouts Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its goal is to support safe use of roundabouts; the bill itself does not set new driving rules.

  • It would let the Minister make regulations setting rules of the road for roundabouts. “May” means the Minister has the power, but is not required to use it.
  • Before making a regulation, the Minister would have to study roundabout safety and consult members of the public.
  • The study would have to cover crosswalks; signs and markings; lighting; commercial vehicles; speed limits; signalling; entering and exiting; uniform road-design standards, including lane-width consistency; compliance with accessibility standards under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005; and any other matter the Minister considers appropriate.
  • If no regulation is made, the Minister would have to table an annual report describing the required study and consultations and progress on developing a regulation. This reporting duty would end once a regulation is made.
  • The study and consultation duties would not apply to regulations that amend, remake or revoke the first regulation made under the new power.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers and other road users: The bill would not directly change how you must use a roundabout when it takes effect. Any new rules would depend on regulations the Minister may make later.
  • The Minister: Before making a regulation, the Minister would have to conduct the study and consult the public. If no regulation is made, annual progress reports would be required.
  • The public: The bill requires public consultation before a regulation, but does not set out how people can take part or require that any particular public views be adopted.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the current Highway Traffic Act, so I could not verify what roundabout rules or related regulatory powers already exist.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires a study, public consultation and, while no regulation has been made, annual reports. It gives no cost estimate or staffing details.
  • The bill does not set a tax, fee or fine, or specify an amount of spending.

What is unclear#

  • The bill sets no deadline for completing the study, consulting the public or making regulations.
  • It does not specify how the study or consultation must be done, or whether the study must be published.
  • “Members of the public” is not further defined, and the bill does not say how consultation views would affect the regulations.
  • The bill does not state what rules the regulations would establish, or how they would interact with existing rules.
  • The bill text says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish its legislative status.

Case for#

  • A study covering safety, accessibility and road design could give the Minister a basis for considering roundabout rules.
  • Public consultation before the first regulation could bring public input into that work.
  • Regulations could allow rules to be set for roundabouts without the bill itself fixing every road rule.

Case against#

  • The Minister may make regulations but is not required to do so. The bill therefore does not guarantee that new roundabout rules will be established.
  • With no deadline, the study, consultation or decision to make regulations could take an unclear amount of time.
  • The bill does not require study and consultation before regulations that amend, remake or revoke the first regulation.
  • The bill leaves the actual rules, study process and consultation method open, so the safety and accessibility effects cannot be judged from this text alone.