Summary#
Bill 192, the Protecting Small Business Act, 2020, amended Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act. It created temporary limits on some landlords’ actions against tenants with rent arrears; the stated goal was to protect small businesses during the pandemic. The Act was enacted as Chapter 10 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2020.
- The rules applied to tenancies where the landlord was eligible for Canada Emergency Commercial Rent Assistance (CECRA), or would be eligible if the landlord agreed to a rent reduction and eviction moratorium.
- During the non-enforcement period, a judge could not make a writ of possession (an order allowing the landlord to take back the premises) effective for rent arrears. Landlords also could not re-enter premises or seize goods for rent arrears.
- For certain re-entries and seizures between May 1, 2020 and the start of the period, landlords had to restore possession or return unsold goods. If possession could not be restored for reasons other than the tenant declining it, the landlord had to compensate the tenant for damages.
- These protections had exceptions for specified actions taken after the landlord was approved for CECRA assistance. The rules were set to end September 1, 2020, or earlier by proclamation.
What it means for you#
- Small-business tenants in covered tenancies: The rules temporarily limited landlords’ ability to take back premises or seize goods. They did not cancel rent arrears or prevent every kind of eviction.
- Tenants whose landlord had already re-entered or seized goods: Depending on the timing and circumstances, the landlord had to restore possession, return unsold goods, or compensate the tenant for damages. Restored tenancies were on the same terms unless landlord and tenant agreed otherwise.
- Landlords: Covered landlords had to follow the temporary restrictions and restoration duties, subject to the CECRA approval exceptions. A landlord who breached the restrictions or failed to meet certain duties could be liable for damages.
- Other tenants and the public: The text does not directly change their rights or services. These protections were time-limited and are not ongoing under this Act’s stated dates.
Money#
No publicly available information on the Act’s public cost.
- The Act gives no estimate of staffing, administration, or compliance costs.
- Landlords could be required to pay tenant damages in some cases. The Act gives no estimate of those amounts.
What is unclear#
- The supplied text does not explain how landlords’ CECRA eligibility would be checked or how disputes about eligibility would be handled.
- It gives no process, deadlines, or appeal route for tenants seeking restoration or compensation.
- The exact date the temporary period began is not stated in the supplied material; it began when the relevant provision came into force.
- The Commercial Tenancies Act itself was not supplied, so the Act’s changes cannot be checked against the full prior law or verified against current law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to keep eligible small-business tenants from losing their premises or goods over rent arrears during a temporary crisis.
- Requiring landlords to restore possession or return unsold goods addressed some actions taken shortly before the restrictions began.
- Limiting the rules when a landlord was approved for CECRA assistance tied the protections to a rent-support program.
Case against#
- The protections depended on the landlord’s CECRA eligibility, and some restrictions stopped applying to specified actions after the landlord was approved. The bill does not explain how tenants would know whether an exception applied.
- The text leaves key practical details, including how eligibility disputes and compensation claims would be handled, unsettled.
- The rules were temporary. They did not erase rent arrears or create lasting protection from loss of premises for non-payment.