9-1-1 overhaul targets dispatch staff

Summary#

Bill 56, the 9-1-1 Everywhere in Ontario Act, 2021, would create a new Act and amend Ontario’s Ombudsman Act. Its stated goal is to improve 9-1-1 services and oversight; it does not guarantee a particular emergency response or outcome.

  • The Solicitor General, or another minister assigned the Act, would have to take all necessary steps to provide specified 9-1-1 infrastructure across Ontario, including compatible computer-aided dispatch systems and updated caller-location information.
  • The minister would also have to establish an interoperable radio channel for multi-agency responses, investigate ways to help call-centre staff hear and understand communications, and ensure water-rescue resources are identified in every municipality and that call-takers and dispatchers can access that information.
  • People and entities operating relevant 9-1-1 call centres would have to meet duties on staffing, training, staff support, communications, dispatch information, and compatible systems. They would also have to make and train staff on a policy covering specified procedures, including internal reviews in certain cases involving a death.
  • The Ombudsman would designate an Assistant Ombudsman from among the Ombudsman’s employees to oversee 9-1-1 operations. The assistant would help with certain investigations, carry out other listed duties, and publish an annual report.

What it means for you#

  • People calling 9-1-1: The minister would have to take steps to ensure a call from anywhere in Ontario connects to a 9-1-1 call centre for police, ambulance and fire services, or to the police service responsible for that area. This is an infrastructure duty, not a guarantee of response time or outcome.
  • Call-centre operators: They would have to ensure staffing is suitable for call volumes and that supervisors can focus on supervising rather than taking calls or dispatching. They would also have to provide specified training and supports, including mental-health and post-traumatic-stress-disorder supports. The bill does not set staffing numbers or service standards.
  • Call-takers, dispatchers and emergency responders: The bill would require call centres to ensure staff can monitor dispatch information at all times and that responders can communicate directly with other responders and dispatchers. Operators would also have to train staff on the required policy.
  • People whose 9-1-1 service is connected to a death: If an internal review is triggered, it must include staff consultations during and after the review. The Assistant Ombudsman would have to provide a close relative information related to an Ombudsman investigation concerning the death.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill would add an oversight role inside the existing Ombudsman’s office, not create a separate independent agency. The assistant would also have to run a public awareness campaign, investigate ways to deter inappropriate or accidental calls, and publish an annual report.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill would require the minister to take steps to provide infrastructure and would impose staffing, training, support and system duties on call-centre operators, but it gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • It does not set a fee, tax, fine or benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms such as “appropriately staffed,” “adequately trained” or “appropriate supports.” The minister may require industry-recognized certifications, but the bill does not say which ones.
  • It does not set out how the minister would ensure the infrastructure is provided, or what happens if a minister or operator does not meet a duty. It gives no inspection or penalty process.
  • It does not specify how the Ombudsman’s investigations would work or what information the assistant could access. The Ombudsman Act and other current-law materials were not supplied, so the existing investigation powers and oversight arrangements could not be checked.
  • The bill sets system deadlines of December 2023 and January 1, 2024, but does not explain how they would apply if the Act came into force after those dates. It would come into force on Royal Assent.
  • It does not explain how call-centre operators would be involved in setting technical requirements, or how the duties would overlap with existing arrangements.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address gaps in communication and information-sharing during emergency calls. Compatible dispatch systems and updated caller-location information could help emergency services share information.
  • A shared radio channel could support communication during a response involving more than one service.
  • Staffing and support duties could help call centres manage demand and support workers who handle difficult calls.
  • Required internal reviews in specified cases could help identify concerns about how 9-1-1 services were provided.

Case against#

  • The bill sets broad duties but leaves important standards undefined, including what staffing, training and support are adequate. That could make it difficult to know what compliance requires.
  • It requires major infrastructure and staffing changes but provides no cost estimate or funding plan. The expense and how it would be shared are unclear.
  • The bill sets duties but does not state a penalty or enforcement process for non-compliance.
  • The Assistant Ombudsman’s role is detailed, but the bill does not explain the resources or access to information needed to carry it out.