Overhauls 9-1-1 systems and Ombudsman oversight

Summary#

Bill 107, the 9-1-1 Everywhere in Ontario Act, 2023, would create a new Act and amend Ontario’s Ombudsman Act. Its stated goal is to improve 9-1-1 infrastructure, call-centre operations and oversight. The bill says it would start on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not establish whether it became law.

  • The Solicitor General, or another minister assigned to administer the Act, would have to take all necessary steps to provide province-wide 9-1-1 connections and specified dispatch, location-sharing and water-rescue information systems. The minister would also have to establish an interoperable radio channel and investigate ways to help call-centre staff hear and understand callers and colleagues.
  • Operators of 9-1-1 call centres for police, ambulance and fire services would have to meet duties on staffing, training, staff supports, communications and dispatch systems, and create and train staff on a policy covering seven listed matters.
  • The Ombudsman would have to designate an existing employee as an Assistant Ombudsman for 9-1-1 operations. The assistant would support relevant investigations, provide certain information to close relatives after an investigation into a death, run a public-awareness campaign, investigate ways to deter inappropriate or accidental calls, and publish an annual report.
  • The proposed deadlines for compatible dispatch systems are December 2023 for the required infrastructure and January 1, 2024 for call centres to operate on the system.

What it means for you#

  • People calling 9-1-1: The bill would require infrastructure intended to connect anyone in Ontario who dials 9-1-1 to a call centre or the police service responsible for that area. It does not set a response-time guarantee.
  • Call-centre operators and staff: Operators would have to ensure centres are appropriately staffed, provide specified training and supports, and meet the other operating duties. Their policy would have to explain how callers unable to speak can communicate by other means, when responders may speak directly with callers, and how certain dispatch decisions and delays are handled. It would also require an internal review in specified cases involving a death and a concern about how 9-1-1 services were provided.
  • Close relatives of someone who died: If the Ombudsman conducts an investigation relating to 9-1-1 services and the investigation concerns that person’s death, the Assistant Ombudsman would have to provide a close relative with information related to the investigation. The bill does not require an investigation after every death.
  • The Ombudsman’s office: The assistant would be an Ombudsman employee, not a new independent body. The bill gives the assistant the listed duties but does not set out a separate complaint process.
  • Taxpayers and municipalities: The bill assigns duties involving province-wide infrastructure and water-rescue information, but does not specify how those duties would be divided or delivered locally.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • The bill would require call-centre operators to provide staffing, training and supports, including mental-health and post-traumatic-stress-disorder supports. It gives no cost estimate.
  • The minister would have to take steps on infrastructure and a radio channel, but the bill does not state a budget, funding source or staffing level.
  • The bill does not specify fees, fines or a new benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The Ombudsman Act is not included in the supplied material, so the existing scope of Ombudsman investigations and the bill’s effect on current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how its 2023 and 2024 system deadlines would work if it started after those dates. The supplied material also does not establish its current status.
  • Terms such as “appropriately staffed,” “adequately trained” and “industry recognized” are not defined. The bill does not set out enforcement powers or penalties for failing to meet the call-centre duties.
  • The bill does not set out how the minister would consult municipalities or service operators, or how infrastructure and water-rescue information would be funded and maintained.
  • It does not specify how the required internal reviews would be conducted, beyond the matters the policy must cover and the requirement to consult staff during and after the review.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that dispatchers and emergency responders need compatible systems and direct ways to share information during emergencies.
  • Requiring updated caller-location information and water-rescue resources to be available to call takers could help them access important details when handling calls.
  • Requirements for staffing, training, supervision and mental-health supports could give call-centre staff clearer operating expectations.
  • A dedicated Assistant Ombudsman and public annual report could make 9-1-1 oversight more visible.

Case against#

  • The bill sets broad duties but leaves key standards, enforcement and implementation details open. That could make it hard to tell whether operators have met requirements such as appropriate staffing.
  • The infrastructure, staffing and support duties could cost money, but no estimate or funding plan is provided.
  • The system deadlines are dated 2023 and 2024. If the bill starts later, the text does not say whether or how those deadlines would change.
  • The bill requires some internal reviews and gives the assistant specified duties, but does not create a general process for public complaints or require an Ombudsman investigation in every case involving a death.