9-1-1 Everywhere Bill Expands Emergency Reach

Summary#

Bill 75, the 9-1-1 Everywhere in Ontario Act, 2019, would create a new law and amend the Ombudsman Act. Its stated goal is province-wide access to 9-1-1, through duties on the minister and 9-1-1 call-centre operators.

  • The Minister of Community Safety and Correctional Services would have to take all necessary steps to ensure that anyone in Ontario who calls 9-1-1 is connected to an appropriate call centre or local police service.
  • The minister would also have to work toward compatible computer-aided dispatch systems by December 2023, establish an interoperable radio channel for multi-agency responses, and ensure water-rescue resources are identified in every municipality and shared with 9-1-1 staff.
  • Call-centre operators would have to ensure adequate staffing, training and staff supports, among other duties. They would also have to use compatible dispatch systems by January 1, 2024, and put in place a policy covering specified call-handling and review matters.
  • The Ombudsman would have to designate an existing employee as an Assistant Ombudsman for 9-1-1 operations. The assistant would help with investigations, carry out other listed duties, and publish an annual report.

What it means for you#

  • People calling 9-1-1: The minister would have to ensure infrastructure connects calls to a call centre or local police service. The bill does not guarantee a particular response time or outcome.
  • Call-centre staff and supervisors: Operators would have to provide appropriate staffing, training and supports, including mental-health and post-traumatic stress disorder supports. Supervisors could not be required to take calls or dispatch while doing their supervisory duties.
  • Call-centre operators: They would have to make policies on communication options for callers unable to speak, direct communication between responders and callers, medical responses, dispatch delays, supervisor consultation, and critical information in radio communications. The policy must also require an internal review when 9-1-1 services relate to a death and a close relative or service provider raises a concern.
  • Municipalities and emergency services: Water-rescue resources would have to be identified in every municipality and that information made available to 9-1-1 call takers, dispatchers and supervisors.
  • The public and people whose relatives die: The Assistant Ombudsman would have to run a public-awareness campaign, investigate ways to deter inappropriate or accidental 9-1-1 use, and provide a close relative with information about a related Ombudsman investigation.
  • No new independent Ombudsman body: The assistant would be designated from among existing Ombudsman employees. The bill does not set out a new application or appeal process for callers.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require infrastructure, staffing, training and staff supports, but gives no cost estimate, funding source or staffing number.
  • It does not specify a new tax, fee, fine or benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms such as “all necessary steps,” “appropriately staffed” or “adequately trained.”
  • It does not say who would pay for or maintain the required infrastructure, or how the minister would ensure it is in place.
  • It gives no technical standards or details about how the compatible dispatch systems or interoperable radio channel would work.
  • It does not explain how the Minister would set any required professional certification, or how compliance with the operator duties would be enforced.
  • It does not explain how the Ombudsman’s existing investigations would relate to the new assistant’s work, beyond saying the assistant would help.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that reliable connections and shared information among emergency services matter when calls need a quick response.
  • Requiring compatible dispatch systems and a shared radio channel could help services communicate during a multi-agency response.
  • Staffing, training and mental-health support duties could address pressure points for call-centre workers.
  • Requiring internal reviews in specified cases involving a death could help identify concerns about how 9-1-1 services were provided.

Case against#

  • The bill sets broad duties but does not provide cost estimates, funding or a detailed plan for delivering the required infrastructure.
  • Operators would have to meet many duties, but the bill does not specify how “appropriate” staffing or “adequate” training would be measured or enforced.
  • The minister would have power to require industry-recognized professional certification, but the bill does not explain what certification would qualify.
  • The required internal reviews apply only in the stated circumstances; the bill does not set out a general review process, timelines or appeals.