Summary#
Bill 179, the Fewer Backlogs and Less Partisan Tribunals Act, 2024, would create a new Ontario law and amend the Adjudicative Tribunals Accountability, Governance and Appointments Act, 2009. Its stated goal is to support accessible, timely, expert, inclusive, impartial and just decisions by tribunals; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.
- It would establish an Adjudicative Tribunal Justice Council, which could hire staff. The Council would monitor tribunals, identify problems, advise government and the Legislature, and report on deficiencies and possible improvements.
- Before a new tribunal member is appointed, the responsible Minister would need a Council-approved recruitment plan and a selection committee. The committee would recommend the most qualified candidates while also considering the diversity of the tribunal’s community of users.
- The bill would set default appointment terms and renewal rules, and add review or dismissal procedures for certain non-renewals.
- Tribunal positions would generally be treated as permanent roster positions. A responsible Minister could declare positions redundant after preparing a plan and considering the Council’s opinion.
- The Council could require information from tribunals and would have to survey tribunal users when it determines that doing so is practical.
- The bill would generally prevail over conflicting provisions in other Acts unless they expressly override it. That override would expire after three years unless renewed or expressly made to last beyond that period.
What it means for you#
- People using tribunals: The Council could monitor how tribunals work and ask for information, but the bill does not create a new service or give users a new appeal. The Council must not review the merits of an individual tribunal decision.
- Tribunal applicants: New appointments would follow recruitment plans approved by the Council and committee recommendations. The government could defer or reject a recommendation, but would have to give written reasons to the Council; the committee would then reconsider or recommend another candidate.
- Tribunal members: The bill sets term and renewal rules. Some members could seek a confidential Council review of a non-renewal without just cause; alleged just-cause cases would involve an independent review or hearing process. Members whose positions are declared redundant must complete outstanding decisions, and may continue cases already underway with the chair’s approval.
- Government and tribunals: The Council would have monitoring and reporting duties, could conduct inquiries, and could require tribunals to provide specified information by a deadline. Ministers would have to give the Council at least six months’ written notice of certain planned legislation, regulations or directives affecting tribunals.
- Tribunal users and advocates: Tribunals would have to provide contact information for people covered by the Council’s satisfaction survey. The Council must keep that information confidential and use it only for the survey.
Money#
The bill allows the Council to hire staff and carry out its duties, but no cost estimate is available.
- The bill does not set a budget or limit the number of Council employees.
- A roster-reduction plan must describe notice and compensation for affected members, but the bill does not set the amounts.
- No publicly available information.
What is unclear#
- The Adjudicative Tribunals Accountability, Governance and Appointments Act, 2009 was not supplied, so its current appointment rules and the exact effect of the amendments could not be verified.
- The bill does not set a fixed deadline for starting the user survey; it begins when the Council decides it is practical.
- It does not define terms such as “community of users,” “just cause” or “substantial deficiencies.”
- It does not specify how the Council would investigate concerns, choose survey questions, or ensure its recommendations are acted on.
- The Council could make regulations changing some appointment-term rules, subject to approval by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. The bill does not specify what changes would be made.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address tribunal vacancies, delays and other shortcomings through ongoing monitoring and public reporting.
- A Council with members appointed through several routes could bring tribunal, legal and community perspectives to that work.
- Recruitment plans, selection committees and written reasons for rejecting or delaying recommendations could make appointments more transparent and structured.
- Reviewing proposed tribunal-related changes in advance could help identify effects on tribunal operations before those changes take effect.
Case against#
- The Council would have broad monitoring and inquiry powers, but the bill does not fully set out how inquiries would work or how the Council would be held accountable for its judgments.
- Requiring Council approval of recruitment plans and adding committee steps could add time or process to appointments; the bill does not set an overall deadline for completing them.
- The bill permits roster reductions, and the Council’s opinion does not bind the Minister. Members could lose positions even if the Council objects.
- Staffing, surveys, inquiries and reviews could require public money, but the bill gives no cost estimate.