Mayors gain power to drive housing

Summary#

Bill 3, the Strong Mayors, Building Homes Act, 2022, was enacted as Chapter 18 of Ontario’s 2022 statutes. It amends the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, is to support building homes; the bill does not require a specific number of homes to be built.

  • It gives Toronto’s mayor, and mayors in municipalities designated by the Minister, new powers over the chief administrative officer, municipal organization and some employment matters, local boards, committees and budgets.
  • A mayor may direct municipal employees in writing to research or advise on matters related to these powers, or to carry out related duties, including implementing the mayor’s decisions.
  • If provincial priorities are prescribed, a mayor may require council to consider a matter the mayor thinks could advance a priority, and may veto certain by-laws the mayor thinks could interfere with one. Council can override a by-law veto with a two-thirds vote.
  • A mayor must prepare a proposed municipal budget. Council may amend it; the mayor may veto an amendment, and council may override that veto with a two-thirds vote. Regulations govern the budget process.
  • The new powers have limits. They do not include hiring or dismissing specified officials, such as the clerk, treasurer, integrity commissioner, ombudsman, auditor general, police chief or fire chief. A mayor with a financial interest in a matter must disclose it and not use the relevant power or try to influence the decision.

What it means for you#

  • Residents and taxpayers: The bill does not directly change your taxes, fees, services or housing eligibility. It changes who has authority over some municipal decisions.
  • Municipal councils: Councils may face mayoral directions on what matters to consider. They can override certain mayoral vetoes only with a two-thirds vote.
  • Mayors and municipal staff: Mayors gain the powers described above. They must exercise powers under these parts in writing and make prescribed information public. The bill does not itself set all the rules for how these powers are used.
  • Municipal employees and officials: A mayor may change the organizational structure and may hire or dismiss some division or organization heads. The listed protected officials are excluded from those employment powers.
  • Municipalities outside Toronto: The rules in the Municipal Act apply only to municipalities designated by the Minister. The bill does not name them in the supplied text.

Money#

No publicly available information on the fiscal cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not state a spending amount or create a tax, fee or fine.
  • Mayors may direct municipal employees to do related work, and must prepare proposed budgets. The material gives no estimate of staff time or other costs.
  • Regulations may set further rules for the powers and budget process.

What is unclear#

  • Which municipalities, local boards and committees are covered depends in part on regulations; the supplied material does not identify them.
  • Provincial priorities must be prescribed before the meeting and by-law powers tied to those priorities apply. The supplied material does not say what the priorities are.
  • Regulations may set important details, including budget procedures, public information requirements, deadlines and limits on mayoral powers. Those details are not in the supplied text.
  • The bill’s schedules take effect on dates set by proclamation. No proclamation dates are included in the supplied material, so the start date of each schedule is unclear.
  • The text does not set housing targets or require a particular housing outcome.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give mayors clearer authority and responsibility over municipal leadership, organization and budgets.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that one elected official may be able to coordinate municipal decisions around provincial priorities, including housing-related priorities if prescribed.
  • Written decisions, public disclosure rules set by regulation, and the two-thirds override votes provide some checks on mayoral authority.
  • The bill preserves specified independent and legally required municipal offices from the mayor’s hiring and dismissal powers.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that the mayor gains substantial authority over staffing, committees and budgets, while council needs a two-thirds vote to override certain mayoral decisions.
  • The meeting and by-law powers depend on provincial priorities, but the bill does not define those priorities in the supplied text. The mayor’s opinion that a by-law could potentially interfere with a priority is enough to trigger the veto process.
  • Many practical rules are left to regulations, so the bill itself does not fully explain how powers, budgets or public disclosure will work.
  • A decision made legally and in good faith cannot be set aside by a court because it is unreasonable. That limits one basis for court review.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2022090801

    Passed105 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 3

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 31

    74For

    • PC74

    31Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2022090802

    Passed105 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 3

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 31

    74For

    • PC74

    31Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2022081801

    Passed94 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 3

    FOR · 72AGAINST · 22

    72For

    • PC72

    22Against

    • NDP19
    • Liberal2
    • Green1
  4. Division No. 2022081802

    Passed97 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 3

    FOR · 72AGAINST · 25

    72For

    • PC72

    25Against

    • NDP19
    • Liberal5
    • Green1