Power plant retirements funded by bonds

Summary#

SB 1120 would amend Wisconsin law on environmental trust bonds; it would not create a new law. Its goal is to let utilities seek bond financing for retiring certain power plants. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • It would add the retirement of any existing electric generating facility fueled by nonrenewable combustible energy resources to the activities eligible for this financing.
  • It would include the retired property’s unrecovered value and demolition or similar costs above the property’s salvage value among eligible costs.
  • An energy utility would still have to apply to the Public Service Commission (PSC), and the PSC would have to approve an order before the utility could use this financing.
  • The bonds would be supported by charges paid by the utility’s customers. The bill would not make a utility apply or require the PSC to approve an application.
  • Fines, penalties, and forfeitures assessed against a utility would remain excluded from eligible costs.

What it means for you#

  • Electric customers: If a utility applied and the PSC approved, customer charges could support bonds for retiring an eligible facility and the costs of financing those bonds. The bill does not set the amount of any charge.
  • Energy utilities: They could apply to finance these newly eligible retirement costs through environmental trust bonds. Approval would remain with the PSC.
  • The PSC: It would continue to decide whether to issue an order allowing this financing.
  • General public: The bill would not itself order a power plant to retire or require utilities to apply for financing.

Money#

The bill would make certain plant-retirement costs eligible for customer-backed bond financing, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate.

  • The bill does not directly appropriate money or set a fee or charge.
  • The supplied material says a state fiscal estimate would be printed as an appendix, but does not include it. No publicly available information on the estimated costs or customer charges.
  • The bill would include unrecovered property value and certain demolition or similar costs in eligible costs; it would exclude government-assessed fines, penalties, and forfeitures.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material describes current law, but does not include the current statutory text. I could not verify that description against the full current law.
  • The bill does not define “nonrenewable combustible energy resources” or explain what qualifies as “retiring” a facility.
  • It does not set application rules, decision standards, timelines, customer protections, or reporting requirements.
  • It does not explain how the PSC would assess the costs, including the unrecovered value of property or demolition costs.
  • The supplied material does not explain how this financing would interact with other utility programs or cost-recovery rules.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that retiring a qualifying power plant can involve large costs, including property value that has not yet been recovered and demolition costs. The bill would allow utilities to seek a bond-financing route for those costs.
  • Requiring a PSC order means the financing would not be automatic; the PSC would have to approve it.
  • Excluding fines and penalties means those costs could not be shifted into this bond financing.

Case against#

  • One concern is that customers could be charged for financing a plant’s retirement, including unrecovered property value and demolition costs above salvage value.
  • The bill does not set limits or decision standards for the costs a utility could ask the PSC to approve.
  • It is unclear how the PSC would weigh customer charges against the utility’s requested financing, or what opportunity customers would have to challenge the costs.