Power utilities face carbon-free targets by 2050

Summary#

SB 1150, titled “Net zero emissions, carbon-free and renewable energy standards, and creating an office of sustainability and clean energy,” would amend Wisconsin statutes, including the state’s renewable-energy law, and create new requirements. It failed and is not law. Its stated goal is for Wisconsin to reach 100% clean electricity and emit no more carbon than can be removed economy-wide by 2050.

  • It would create an Office of Sustainability and Clean Energy inside the Department of Administration. The secretary of administration would direct it to develop and periodically update an economy-wide decarbonization roadmap.
  • Electric providers would have to meet rising carbon-free electricity targets: 50% by 2030, 65% by 2035, 80% by 2040, 90% by 2045 and 100% by 2050. They would also have to meet separate renewable-energy targets: 20% by 2030, 40% by 2035 and 60% by 2040.
  • State agencies would face rising carbon-free electricity requirements for their facilities. Starting in 2030, they could no longer rely on an existing exemption when buying or generating renewable electricity is not technically feasible or cost-effective.
  • Electric providers would have to submit transition plans to the Public Service Commission (PSC). The PSC could approve a plan only if it would meet the applicable target, protect grid reliability and make continued use or retirement of non-carbon-free facilities the most cost-effective choice for customers.
  • The bill would set conditions for PSC approval of certain large power projects, including wage and hiring provisions. It would also require good-faith apprentice use and monthly reporting on qualifying construction projects.
  • If a provider did not follow a PSC order to meet an energy requirement or carry out an approved transition plan, it could face a forfeiture of up to the estimated cost of compliance.

What it means for you#

  • Electric customers: Providers could recover from ratepayers the minimum costs needed to meet the standards. The PSC would have to balance that recovery with the need for affordable electricity.
  • Electric providers: They would have to meet both sets of electricity targets, report on compliance, and submit transition plans. Carbon-free energy bought from a supplier could count only if generated in the specified Midcontinent Independent System Operator regions.
  • State agencies: Their electricity use would have to meet the new carbon-free targets, subject to rules about which electricity counts.
  • Power-project applicants and construction firms: The bill would make wage and hiring commitments part of some large-project approvals. On qualifying projects costing at least $10 million, contractors and subcontractors would have to make good-faith efforts to meet apprentice-use targets and file monthly reports. Missing a target would require an explanation and supporting documents; failure to provide them could lead to a forfeiture.
  • Everyone else: The 2050 economy-wide target is a legal goal for the state, not a guaranteed result or a new individual service. The bill would not itself require households to replace equipment or change their energy use.

Money#

The bill authorizes an amount sufficient for technology needed to implement it, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate.

  • Utilities could recover minimum compliance costs from ratepayers, subject to PSC review.
  • Staffing for the new office and the cost of the roadmap are not specified.
  • No publicly available information on the appropriation’s dollar amount or the bill’s overall fiscal estimate is included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The roadmap must be updated “periodically,” but the bill does not set an update schedule or spell out how the roadmap would be used.
  • The bill does not provide a detailed accounting method for the 2050 economy-wide emissions goal.
  • The PSC would set deadlines for transition plans; the bill does not give those deadlines.
  • The supplied bill text ends partway through the project-approval provisions, so their full details could not be checked.
  • The current statutes being amended were not supplied. The bill material describes the existing renewable standard, but does not allow a full comparison of every amended provision with current law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that staged targets give electric providers time to plan for a major change in how electricity is produced.
  • Requiring transition plans would give the PSC a way to assess whether providers can meet targets while protecting reliability and customer costs.
  • Separate renewable and carbon-free targets would set a minimum for renewables as well as for carbon-free electricity, which the bill defines to include sources such as nuclear power.
  • The project provisions could connect some new construction to wage standards, local hiring efforts and apprentice training.

Case against#

  • One concern is that meeting rising targets could increase costs, and the bill allows some of those costs to be passed on to customers.
  • The bill creates demanding targets but leaves important choices—such as transition-plan deadlines and some accounting rules—to later PSC action.
  • The PSC’s cost-effectiveness and reliability tests could limit or complicate project and retirement decisions; the bill does not show how those judgments would work in practice.
  • The office, roadmap and technology appropriation could require public resources, but the supplied material does not quantify them.