Bond financing for early facility retirements

Summary#

SB 1152, titled Requirements for granting a certificate for certain electric facilities and use of environmental trust bonds to finance the costs of retiring electric facilities, would amend Wisconsin law on facility approvals and utility financing. Its goal is to link approval of some electric facilities to a plan for financing their costs if they are retired before their value is fully recovered. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The Public Service Commission (PSC) would have to decide whether a proposed facility would primarily serve a “very large customer,” defined as an electric utility customer with a load of at least 75 megawatts.
  • If so, the PSC would have to reject the certificate application unless it orders or requires the utility to obtain a financing order for the facility’s unrecovered value if the facility is retired early.
  • The bill would let the PSC order or require a utility to use environmental trust bonds for early retirement costs when it finds that doing so is in the public interest.
  • It would expand eligible bond costs to include retiring any existing facility, not only retirement tied to reducing or controlling pollution.
  • The certificate rule would apply to certificates issued on the bill’s effective date. The bill does not require a facility to be built or retired, or require bonds to be issued immediately.

What it means for you#

  • Electric utility customers: If bonds are used, the existing financing system recovers costs and bond-financing costs through charges paid by utility customers. The bill does not say how those charges would be allocated among customers.
  • Electric utilities: A utility seeking a certificate for a facility primarily serving a customer with a load of at least 75 megawatts could not receive approval unless the PSC orders or requires a financing order for possible early-retirement costs.
  • Large customers: The bill does not directly change a customer’s eligibility for service or set a special charge for customers meeting the 75-megawatt threshold.
  • The PSC: It would have a new required decision in relevant certificate applications and could order or require bond financing for early retirement when it finds that is in the public interest.

Money#

No publicly available information on an estimated cost is in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation or estimate for public spending or staffing.
  • Environmental trust bonds would be repaid through utility customer charges that cover the eligible costs and the cost of financing.
  • Eligible costs could include a facility’s unrecovered value and certain demolition or similar costs above the property’s salvage value; monetary penalties and fines are excluded.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define how the PSC should decide whether a facility would “primarily serve” a very large customer.
  • It does not set out how the PSC would calculate or allocate early-retirement costs among customers.
  • The bill does not describe the timing or process for obtaining the financing order beyond referring to existing law.
  • The supplied material does not include the amended statutes themselves. The Legislative Reference Bureau analysis describes current law, but I could not independently verify that description against the full current statutory text.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the risk that a facility built mainly to serve a very large customer may be retired before the utility has recovered its full value.
  • Requiring a financing plan as a condition of approval could make that possible future cost part of the PSC’s decision about the facility.
  • Allowing bonds to cover retirement of any existing facility could give the PSC another financing option when early retirement is in the public interest.

Case against#

  • Utility customers could pay for unrecovered facility costs and bond-financing costs, but the bill does not say how those costs would be divided or whether the very large customer would pay a particular share.
  • The bill does not define “primarily serve,” leaving an important approval test to be worked out by the PSC.
  • Extending bond eligibility to retirement of any existing facility is broader than the pollution-related retirement purposes described in current law by the supplied analysis. The bill does not explain what limits would guide that broader use.