Bill loosens permit rules for large energy plants

Summary#

SB 1122 would amend Wisconsin law on electric utility rates and certificates for large generating facilities. It would bar utilities from recovering a return on equity for retired generating facilities, change an existing exemption from certificate requirements, and require the Public Service Commission (PSC) to post permit-status information online. Its stated goal is not provided in the supplied materials. The bill failed and did not become law.

  • An electric public utility could not recover in rates any amount for the return on equity on a retired electric generating facility. The bill does not bar recovery of other costs for that facility.
  • A person could build a large generating facility without a certificate of public convenience and necessity (CPCN) if at least 70% of its output would be used at the site in manufacturing for nonresidential purposes or in specified ferrous mineral mining and processing. The person would have to pay all costs of connecting it to a public utility’s electric infrastructure if it is expected to connect.
  • Current law already allows a CPCN exemption for certain facilities meeting a 70% on-site-use test for manufacturing or ferrous mineral mining. SB 1122 changes the wording and scope of that test.
  • The PSC would have to create and maintain a webpage showing the procedural status of every CPCN application and other permits or approvals needed to build the facility, including federal, state, and local approvals.

What it means for you#

  • Electric utility customers: If enacted, the bill would bar utilities from including a return on equity for retired generating facilities in rates. The materials do not say how much customer bills might change.
  • People or businesses building large generating facilities: Qualifying projects could avoid the CPCN requirement, but would still have to meet the 70% on-site-use test and pay all utility interconnection costs if they expect to connect.
  • People tracking proposed facilities: The PSC would have to post procedural status information for CPCN applications and related permits. The dashboard would not itself grant permits or change approval standards.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it makes no change to current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material; it says a state fiscal estimate would be printed with the bill.

  • The bill would require the PSC to create and maintain a webpage, but the materials give no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill gives no estimate of effects on utility rates or public spending.
  • Qualifying facility builders would have to pay all costs of connecting to a public utility’s electric infrastructure if they expect to connect.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the state fiscal estimate or the bill’s effective date.
  • The bill does not specify how often the PSC must update the dashboard or how it would obtain status information from other governments.
  • The materials do not explain how the PSC would verify the facility’s expected 70% on-site use over time, or what happens if actual use differs.
  • The bill does not explain how the new exemption would interact with other permits or reviews. It would remove the CPCN requirement only for facilities meeting its conditions.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the rate rule is that customers should not pay a return on equity for a generating facility that has retired.
  • A possible argument for the exemption is that a facility using most of its output on site, while paying its own interconnection costs, may not need the same CPCN process.
  • A public permit-status page could make it easier to see where a facility’s approval process stands.

Case against#

  • One concern is that qualifying large facilities would avoid the CPCN requirement, while the bill does not explain how other impacts would be assessed through this exemption.
  • The bill does not set out how the PSC would check the projected on-site use or respond if it is not met.
  • The dashboard could require PSC staff and coordination, but the supplied materials provide no cost estimate or update rules.
  • The materials do not estimate how barring recovery of a return on equity for retired facilities would affect utilities or customer rates.