Fossil Fuel Firms Liable for Climate Harms

Summary#

Bill 21, the Liability for Climate-Related Harms Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law. It would make certain fossil fuel producers strictly liable (liable without proof of fault) for climate-related harms in Ontario, if their greenhouse gas emissions meet a threshold set by regulation. The bill’s stated goal is to make producers contribute to the costs of harms linked to their products and of steps to prevent future harms.

  • The law would apply to corporations, partnerships, trusts and other entities involved in fossil fuel production, including exploration, exploitation and sale.
  • A producer’s emissions would include emissions from producing fossil fuels and from using those fuels. Regulations would determine how emissions are attributed and what level is globally detectable.
  • “Climate-related harms” would include property and infrastructure loss; insurance costs; death, injury, illness and care costs; ocean acidification; sea-level rise; and certain costs for research, emergency response, infrastructure work and public education.
  • Courts could consider scientific, statistical, historical and study-based evidence. For certain weather events, evidence that climate change doubled the likelihood of that type of event would be enough to show, on a balance of probabilities, that climate change caused or worsened the event.
  • A court could include certain future costs if it finds they are reasonably required for planning, starting or completing the listed activities.

What it means for you#

  • Fossil fuel producers: If the legal conditions are met, they could be held liable for climate-related harms occurring in Ontario. The bill does not set a maximum amount of liability or explain how responsibility would be divided among producers.
  • People, businesses and public bodies in Ontario: The listed harms include losses and costs affecting people, property, infrastructure and public services. But the bill does not say who may bring a claim or create an automatic payment or compensation process.
  • General public: The bill does not directly create a tax, ban fossil fuels, or change insurance coverage. It creates civil liability rules; it does not guarantee that any particular person or organization will receive money.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill could expose qualifying producers to liability for damages and for certain reasonable future costs, but it gives no estimate of those amounts.
  • No estimate is provided for government costs to make regulations or for court proceedings.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the “globally detectable” emissions threshold and the method for attributing emissions to producers to regulations. It does not require regulations to be made.
  • It does not explain who can bring a claim, how claims would be started, or what steps or deadlines would apply.
  • It does not set out how liability would be divided among producers, or how a court should deal with other causes of a harm.
  • It does not define how the listed harms and costs would be measured, beyond allowing courts to consider specified types of evidence.
  • The bill says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say when that would occur.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make producers contribute to costs linked to emissions from both producing and using their fossil fuels.
  • Including property damage, health harms and public costs could let claims address a wider range of climate-related losses than property damage alone.
  • Allowing courts to consider scientific models and historical information could help assess harms that are difficult to measure through direct observation alone.
  • Including certain future costs could allow courts to consider reasonable planning and preparation costs before all the work is complete.

Case against#

  • Strict liability could impose substantial costs on producers without requiring proof that they acted negligently. The bill sets no cap on liability.
  • The emissions threshold and attribution rules are left to regulations, and the bill does not explain how responsibility would be shared among producers.
  • The event evidence rule could make it easier to establish that climate change caused or worsened some events, but the bill does not explain how courts should assess other possible causes.
  • The bill creates liability but leaves key parts of the claims process—including who may sue and how claims would be handled—unexplained.