Climate-harm Liability for Fossil Fuels

Summary#

Bill 37, the Liability for Climate-Related Harms Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law. It would make qualifying fossil-fuel producers strictly liable (liable without proof of fault) for climate-related harms in Ontario. The bill’s stated goal is to make producers contribute to the costs of climate-related harm and prevention.

  • A producer would be covered if greenhouse-gas emissions linked to its fossil-fuel production reach a globally detectable level, as determined by regulations. “Production” includes exploring for, exploiting and selling fossil fuels.
  • The emissions calculation would include emissions from producing the fuels and from using them.
  • Covered harms include property and health losses, insurance costs, emergency response, and costs to monitor, research, adapt infrastructure and educate the public. Some planning costs could count even before they are incurred, if a court finds them reasonably required.
  • Courts could consider scientific, statistical, historical and study-based evidence. For a particular event, evidence that climate change doubled the likelihood of that type of event would be sufficient to show, on a balance of probabilities, that climate change caused it or worsened its impact.
  • The bill would let the provincial government make regulations on attributing emissions to producers and deciding whether their emissions level is globally detectable.

What it means for you#

  • Fossil-fuel producers: Corporations, partnerships, trusts and other entities engaged in fossil-fuel production could face liability for covered harms in Ontario if they meet the emissions threshold. The bill does not set the threshold itself.
  • People, businesses and public bodies with losses or costs: The bill includes many kinds of harm and response costs, but it does not create automatic payments or explain who can bring a claim.
  • Ontario residents generally: The bill would not itself create a public compensation fund, require anyone to apply for benefits, or guarantee that any particular harm or cost would be paid.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or set fees.
  • Producers’ potential liability would depend on the regulations, evidence and court decisions; the material gives no estimate of that exposure.
  • Some public costs, including emergency response and infrastructure work, are listed as possible climate-related harms, but the bill does not guarantee repayment.

What is unclear#

  • The regulations would determine how emissions are attributed and what counts as globally detectable; those rules are not provided.
  • The bill does not explain how liability would be divided among producers when several contributed to emissions or harm.
  • It does not specify who may sue, how claims would proceed, or what deadlines, defences or limits would apply.
  • “Reasonably required” costs and the broad definition of climate-related harms would be assessed by courts, but the bill gives no further criteria.
  • The bill says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not state its current status.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make producers contribute to harms linked to emissions from both producing and using fossil fuels.
  • Including prevention, adaptation and emergency costs could allow claims for more than immediate damage to property.
  • Allowing courts to use scientific and statistical evidence, including the specified doubled-likelihood evidence for particular events, could help address difficult questions of causation.

Case against#

  • The emissions threshold and attribution rules are left to future regulations, so the bill does not show which producers would be covered.
  • The definition of harms includes a wide range of losses and future planning costs. Without clearer limits or allocation rules, potential liability could be uncertain.
  • The bill does not explain how claims would be brought or how liability would be shared, which could make outcomes difficult to predict.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2018102503

    Defeated71 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 37

    AGAINST · 53FOR · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    53Against

    • PC53

    18For

    • NDP13
    • Liberal4
    • Green1