Fossil Fuel Producers Face Climate Liability

Summary#

Bill 120, the Liability for Climate-Related Harms Act, 2023, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to make fossil fuel producers contribute to the costs of climate-related harms. The bill says it would start on Royal Assent.

  • Corporations, partnerships, trusts and other entities engaged in fossil fuel production would be strictly liable (liable without needing to prove fault) for climate-related harms in Ontario if emissions attributable to them meet a globally detectable level set by regulation.
  • “Production” includes exploring for and exploiting fossil fuel sources, and selling fossil fuels. Emissions counted include those from production and from use of the fuels.
  • Climate-related harms include property loss, health harms, insurance costs, disaster response, and certain costs of research, public education and infrastructure work.
  • Courts could consider scientific or statistical information, models, historical experience and study findings when assessing harms and costs. Evidence that climate change doubled the likelihood of an event would be sufficient to show, on a balance of probabilities, that climate change caused the event or worsened its impact.
  • Courts could also include certain future costs for monitoring, research, emergency response, infrastructure and public education if they find those costs reasonably required for the related work.

What it means for you#

  • Ontario residents and organizations: The bill would make producers legally liable for qualifying harms in Ontario. It does not set out who may bring a claim or create an automatic payment or compensation program.
  • Fossil fuel producers: Entities meeting the emissions threshold could face liability for harms even without proof of fault. The bill does not limit liability to harms directly caused by one producer’s own operations; emissions from use of its fuels also count.
  • Courts: Courts could use the listed forms of evidence and apply the bill’s rule for events whose likelihood climate change has doubled.
  • Governments and public services: Some costs of emergency response, research, infrastructure work and public education could count as harms. The bill does not require any particular project or spending.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill sets no cost estimate, fee, fine, tax or public appropriation.
  • It could make qualifying producers liable for listed harms and certain future costs, but the amount and who would receive any damages are not specified.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations would set how emissions are attributed to a producer and what level counts as globally detectable; none are included in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not explain how liability would be divided among producers when emissions from several sources contribute to a harm.
  • It does not say who may file a claim, set claim procedures or timelines, or explain how this liability would interact with other legal claims.
  • “Reasonably required” future costs and some elements of “climate-related harms” are not further defined.
  • The bill does not say when regulations would be made.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the difficulty of assigning the costs of climate-related harms to fossil fuel producers whose products contribute emissions.
  • Counting emissions from both production and fuel use could connect liability to a wider share of a producer’s contribution.
  • Allowing courts to consider scientific models and other evidence could help assess harms that are difficult to measure through direct observation alone.
  • Including certain future costs could allow courts to consider preparation and prevention, not only losses that have already occurred.

Case against#

  • One concern is that liability could cover broad categories of harm and future costs, while the bill does not explain how costs would be divided among multiple producers.
  • The key emissions threshold and attribution rules are left to regulations, so the bill alone does not show which producers would qualify.
  • The bill does not set out who can make claims or how claims would be handled, leaving important parts of how the law would work unclear.
  • A possible trade-off is that using a doubled likelihood of an event as sufficient evidence may make it easier to establish that climate change caused or worsened a particular event, even when the event has multiple causes.