Public sector bids favor recycled aggregates

Summary#

Bill 23, the Aggregate Recycling Promotion Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend the Aggregate Resources Act. Its stated goal is to have public-sector construction contracts fairly consider aggregates that are not newly produced.

  • Public-sector bodies would be prohibited from rejecting a construction bid solely because the work proposes to use aggregates that are not newly produced.
  • They would also be prohibited from refusing to enter a construction contract solely because it permits or requires using those aggregates.
  • “Public sector” includes Ontario government bodies, municipalities and local boards, school boards, universities, colleges and some other post-secondary institutions, hospitals, health boards, and Hydro One and Ontario Power Generation and their subsidiaries. Regulations could add other bodies.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council could make regulations defining which aggregates count as not newly produced, adding types of construction work or public-sector bodies, and exempting bodies from the law, with conditions or restrictions.
  • The bill does not require public bodies to use these aggregates or choose a bid that proposes using them. It says it would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Public-sector construction buyers: You could not reject a bid, or refuse to enter a contract, for the sole reason that it involves aggregates that are not newly produced. Other reasons for rejecting a bid or not entering a contract are not barred by this bill.
  • Construction bidders and contractors: Your bid could not be excluded just because it proposes using those aggregates. The bill does not guarantee that your bid will be accepted or that a contract will be awarded.
  • Aggregate producers and suppliers: The bill would not ban newly produced aggregates or require buyers to choose other materials.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, or public services. The supplied material does not establish what procurement rules currently apply.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill creates duties for public-sector bodies but provides no estimate of staffing, administration, or other costs.
  • It does not set a fee, fine, or payment, or provide funding.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “aggregates that are not newly produced”; regulations could set that definition.
  • It does not set procurement procedures, decision criteria, timelines, appeals, or reporting requirements.
  • It does not explain how the prohibition would interact with existing procurement rules or technical requirements.
  • The supplied material does not establish current procurement rules or the meaning of “aggregate” under the Aggregate Resources Act.
  • Regulations could exempt some bodies or add others, but the bill does not say which would be added or exempted.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that public buyers should not exclude bids just because they propose using aggregates that are not newly produced.
  • This could give such materials a fair chance to be considered while leaving public bodies able to assess bids for other reasons.
  • The bill’s stated goal is to balance primary aggregate extraction with secondary aggregate recycling and support sustainable, operationally and economically viable public-sector work.

Case against#

  • The bill does not require public bodies to use aggregates that are not newly produced or select bids that propose them, so the practical effect could be limited.
  • It leaves the key term “aggregates that are not newly produced” to regulations, and does not set criteria for evaluating those materials.
  • The broad power to add exemptions could reduce which public bodies are covered; the bill does not set limits on those exemptions.
  • Without procedures or reporting requirements, it is unclear how compliance would be checked.